| |
|
| 1976 |
Family Plot/Familiengrab |
|
>>> In the scene where Bruce Dern
and Barbara Harris are eating hamburgers. He has two on his plate, from a
back view she reaches over and takes one. He then removes the cap from the
ketchup bottle. The shot switches to a view from his back and the cap is
back on the ketchup. He then removes the cap again. >>> The
amount of beer in George's glass at the diner while waiting for Maloney,
increases after he takes a drink.
>>> Towards the end when George is in the basement, he passes a window that
shows it is day outside, though the scene takes place at night.
>>> When Arthur Adamson opens the garage door Blanche's car is parked
directly in front of it and they are not able to leave. But after taking
care of Blanche the car has not moved and they are still able to leave the
garage. |
|
| 1972 |
Frenzy |
|
>>> Watch the bar scene about ten
minutes from the start of the film. The barmaid is holding 2 pints, but note
how the froth disappears when the shot changes as they are placed on the
bar.
>>> When the potato truck with Rusk searching the
woman's dead body for his R lapel pin is traveling on the highway, the
tailgate is down which allows potatoes to fall out. As the police car passes
the truck, the tailgate is up. When the truck driver stops to check the
tailgate, the tailgate is again down.
>>> The amount of fish soup the inspector has in
his plate changes between shots. The contents of the plate also change and
sometimes we see different fish. >>> The (hanging)
camera tracks backward, turning 180 degrees as it goes down a staircase,
before going out through the front door. As it passes through an internal
doorway within Rusk's house, the door frame can be seen sliding back into
place after (presumably) sliding out of the way to let the camera pass
through it.
>>> After the camera goes back down the staircase and out the front
door into the market, a man walks past with a big sack of tomatoes to cover
the transition from the studio shot to the exterior. Before he passes (the
studio shot), the door frame on the right is clean, but afterwards (the
exterior), a greasy black stain can be seen on the right of the "real" door
frame above the doorbell. Also in the exterior shot, a lampshade and the
shadow of the archway over the interior door can be seen reflected in the
window over the stairs when no such reflection was seen in the studio shot.
>>> The level of the soup in Inspector Oxford's bowl changes
inconsistently throughout the scene.
>>> At the start of the movie Blaney is seen finishing the knot on
his tie. In the next shot (of him coming down the staircase into the bar),
he has the same tie but the colored stripes are different in the knot.
>>> The two strands of the necklace on the detective's wife changes
from being together and being loose while she serves the same meal.
>>> As Blaney talks to Rusk at Covent Garden Market early on in the
film, his cigarette repeatedly jumps back and forth between hand and mouth
between shots.
>>> Mrs Blaney's receptionist estimates Blaney's weight only in
pounds. No English person would do this, and would state the weight more
likely in stones and pounds, or (rarely) in kilogrammes.
>>> The head on the pints of beer disappears between shots as
Maisie brings them to the bar for the doctor and his companion.
>>> As Blaney complains about his "large" brandy, the note
scrunched up in his hand with the glass disappears between shots.
>>> When the driver of the potato lorry stops after spilling his
load, the locking pins on the tailboard differ between shots.
>>> After he orders a triple, Blaney pays the bartender holding the
bill in his left hand from bartender's point of view. The camera switches to
Blaney's point of view and the same bill is in Blaney's right hand.
>>> While Brenda Blaney lies dead in the chair, her stomach is
moving up and down as she breathes.
>>> When Rusk takes Babs to his home he tells her he lives on the
second floor. No English person would say this. From the stairway tracking
shot that follows we see that Rusk lives on the floor above street level
which in England is called the first floor.
>>> As Rusk is leaving Mrs. Blaney's office, he takes another bite
of the apple (previously shown as mostly green but ripening into red) and
sets it on the desk with the green side facing the camera. At the door, as
he turns to see if he's forgotten anything, the closeup shows the apple with
the red side facing towards the camera when it should be facing away from
it. |
|
| 1969 |
Topaz/Topas |
|
>>> In the porcelain
factory, after breaking the statuette, Tamara Kusenov goes through a door to
make a telephone call. The goon following her moves towards the door, now
closed, to investigate it, and the shadow of a man appears briefly on the
wall to the left of the door before we cut away from the shot... and it is
not the shadow of the goon...
>>> As the camera, suspended on a ceiling
track, follows Rico Parra down the crowded hotel corridor in New York, one
of the hanging lights can be seen to suddenly disappear upwards before it
has gone out of shot (allowing the camera to continue forwards).
>>> Later in the film, as the camera
pushes through the open front door into the house party, the closed door to
the left of the screen can be seen to slide out of the way before it has
gone out of shot (allowing the camera to continue forwards).
>>> In the overhead shot as Juanita de
Cordoba sinks down dead, her dress spreads out evenly in all directions, a
brilliant metaphor for the spreading blood pool; however, once she has fully
collapsed (still in the overhead shot), the positions of the wires inside
the dress, which caused it to spread evenly in all directions, are clearly
visible.
>>> Whilst the Mendozas' picnic is being
prepared, the kitchen table can be seen to be built in two halves that split
down the centre, necessary for the trick shot only a moment later when the
camera pushes forwards through the table. |
|
| 1966 |
Torn Curtain/Der zerrissene Vorhang |
|
>>> When Paul Newman takes Julie
Andrews up a small hill to explain that he is not going to work for East
Germany you can see a shot from a distance. It is clear that this scene was
done in a studio, as you can see several lights above the blue background (which
is supposed to be the blue sky).
Nachfolgende 3 Infos stammen von einem
Besucher dieser Homepage (Tonio Gas/28.1.2005): >>>
Als Newman und Kieling zum Landhaus
fahren, fahren sie in einem BMW. Bitte?!? Auch kein Stasi-Scherge hatte einen
solchen!
>>> Bei der langen Busfahrt gibt es Rückprojektionen mit südkalifornischen
Hügellandschaften.
>>> Bei einer Innenaufnahme sieht man im Hintergrund Trümmerlandschaften wie
1945. Man sollte meinen, daß 1966 auch in der sozialistischen Planwirtschaft
alles halbwegs wieder aufgebaut war. >>> A few snippets of
dialogue in the scenes in the East German university clearly show that the
extras are Americans.
>>> Mikrophon sichtbar. Reflected in the window of
the farmhouse as Armstrong enters.
>>> Or their shadow, anyway. On the road-level shot of Armstrong's taxi
leaving the farm (Gromek's motorbike is visible on the left of the screen),
just at the very bottom of the image can be seen the shadow of the camera
(4:3 television version only).
>>> In the farmhouse scene when Professor Armstrong is fighting with Gromek,
Gromek is choking Professor Armstrong but Armstrong shows no signs of it,
i.e. bruising, in later scenes.
>>> When Armstrong and Lindt are in Lindt's workroom, Lindt erases only the
right half of the chalkboard. However, when Armstrong starts writing, the
entire board has been erased. |
|
| 1964 |
Marnie |
|
>>> In the scene where Marnie is
dreaming, watch her window. The curtains move as if there is wind, but the
window is closed.
>>> At the safe, the contents, most noticeably the
cash bundles, move around between shots.
>>>
Marnie's sweater changes after she gets on her horse.
>>> Marnie is obviously riding in front of a
back-projection, as it freezes up as she approaches the wall. >>>
While Rutland and Marnie are at the safe, the stacks of cash change height
and orientation from one shot to the next.
>>> When Marnie is riding the horse toward the wall, at one point
the projected background is stuck and motionless while the horse is
galloping.
>>> Through the porthole on the ship, the water is moving one
direction, but in the next shot it is moving the opposite direction.
>>> When Marnie lets red ink to drop in her blouse sleeve, the spot
appears elongated in the first shot. In the second shot it appears smaller
and rounded.
>>> When Mark and Marnie are at the Rutland's safe, the gun changes
size and color between shots.
>>> When Marnie is about to steal from the Rutland safe a second
time, during the three quick shots of the safe, in the last shot the dial is
in a different position.
>>> When Marnie and Mark are first seen driving to the Rutland
estate in his 1964 Lincoln Continental, the gear shift lever on the steering
wheel remains in the park position.
>>> When Mark is driving with Marnie after confronting her, the
exterior shot shows the Continental in the right lane of the highway, but in
the interior shot that immediately follows, the rear projection shows them
in the left lane.
>>> When Mark and Marnie arrive at Marnie's mother's house, Mark's
shirt is soaking wet, but after Marnie has remembered her childhood the
shirt is completely dry.
>>> Obvious stunt double (different hair) when Marnie rides her
horse after the hunting trip.
>>> When Marnie and Mr. Rutland are at the Atlantic City Race
Courts, there are two drinks on the table. Then Mr. Rutland leaves his seat
to place a bet. When he comes back, the drinks are still there, but in the
next shot, immediately afterward, when they stand up and leave, the drinks
have disappeared.
>>> During the storm scene, Mark leads Marnie to sit on the sofa.
For a moment, you can see Mark's lips moving but you can't hear what he is
saying.
>>> In the beginning of the movie when Marnie visits her mom, she
tells her mom that her boss, Mr. Pemperton, gave her another raise. At the
end of the movie, when Marnie and Mark go to the mom's house to confront her
with the past, the mom says to Mark, "You're not Mr. Pendleton."
>>> When Mark and Marnie return home from their honeymoon, they go
upstairs to their bedroom where Marnie slams the door on the Mark as he's
speaking... but his lips aren't moving.
>>> The shadow of the boom mic falls on the wall of Marnie's
mother's kitchen while she makes Jessie's pie. |
|
| 1963 |
The Birds/Die Vögel |
|
>>> After Melanie has been bandaged up
after her attack, she sits up on the sofa, and you can see two large bloody
scratches on her left cheek. These scratches disappear when Mitch and Lydia
walk Melanie outside to the car.
>>> When Lydia brings out Cathy's
birthday cake, in a wide shot the icing is white, then in a closeup the
icing is a pink colour.
>>> The birds that attack the
schoolchildren have no shadows.
>>> In a scene where Melanie, Mitch and
Cathy are walking to the building on the hill along side Melanie's car, you
can see the camera move in the reflection on the side of the car.
>>> As Lydia gets into her truck you see
a reflection of the stage lights in the steering wheel.
>>> As they all run into the house to get
away from the birds the redheaded boy in the grey-blue suit disappears. He
runs across the lawn at the same time as Annie and the two little girls with
her and should arrive at exactly the same time but we never see him again.
Mitch even looks around in his direction to see if there are any children
still outside before he enters the house. The boy just disappears from this
scene and is not in the last shot of everyone inside the house either.
>>> When Melanie gets up and looks at the
birds massed on the monkey bars the area behind her is a tree and a field.
This background changes entirely when she and Mitch walk up to find Annie's
body and there is what looks like a junk yard with a valley behind it.
>>> When Annie says, "Did you drive up
from San Francisco by the coast road?" her lips are mouthing something
different.
>>> As Melanie and Mitch walk up the hill
behind his house Bodega Bay is at very low tide with a lot of sand bars
showing. When they get to the top of the hill it's high tide.
>>> When going along the water in her
hired boat, Melanie passes a pole bobbing about in the water. In the next
wide shot the pole has vanished.
>>> As Melanie opens the door to the
bedroom there is no light except her flashlight but you can see two distinct
reflections in the door knob, one of the flashlight and one of the studio
light behind her.
>>> The tall structure on the hill behind
the swing set has a lot of clouds around it. When we see it seconds later
the sky is clear.
>>> Before Lydia walks into Mr. Faucet's
room she looks to her left and her face is entirely illuminated by the light
coming from his room. In the next shot as she walks in only the left side of
her face is illuminated.
>>> When everyone begins running down the
hill Melanie is in the middle and Annie is in the back. We're watching
continuous action but several seconds later Melanie jumps to the rear
without ever being passed by Annie.
>>> As Mitch walks up to the garage door
all the birds on the ground that are near him run away and there's nothing
to his right except a garbage pail. Then just before he walks through the
door two birds appear pecking at his feet.
>>> Early in the movie Melanie makes a
right turn as she goes up to Annie's house and we see a white post on the
school side of the street and a stop sign on the opposite side. Now as she
drives up to the school to check on Cathy we see the exact same spot and
there's no stop sign.
>>> As Lydia runs into the house after
arriving back home from the scene at Mr. Faucets house there's a brown shade
at the top on the window to her right. Earlier after the party as she opens
the curtain and looks outside from the dining room, the window has a drape
and a curtain and no brown shade.
>>> The blonde girl in the red with the
red bows in her hair has a crow on her head that suddenly jumps to her right
shoulder between shots.
>>> Melanie walks out from behind the
desk and goes into the hallway to get the nightgown to show Annie. No one
ever flicked a light switch, but the hallway is now very well lit up.
>>> The flashlight is aiming right at the
doorknob before Melanie walks into the room. In the next shot, as she walks
through the door (before they turn the spotlight on) there's no light
because the flashlight is off and isn't pointing at the doorknob.
>>> As they get to the restaurant door,
Melanie is to the right of Mitch, but in the next shot inside the restaurant
she walks around him again to get on his right side.
>>> As Melanie holds out her right hand
to shield the boy in the white jacket we get a really good close-up of his
neck. It was bleeding three shots ago as a crow was attacking him but now
it's not.
>>> As Annie and Melanie speak about how
they met Mitch, watch the shadow move down the front door. A considerable
amount of time has gone by between shots.
>>> As Melanie is inside of the phone
booth a man with birds attacking him runs up to her and there is a clear
shot of the road extending past the restaurant. When this spot is seen
earlier as Mitch and Melanie walk into the restaurant it's entirely
different with a bunch of telephone poles on the left.
>>> In the close-up of the orange car
there's a perfect shot of the cameraman in the bumper as the gas hits the
tire.
>>> When Melanie walks out the door
carrying the tray with the tea pot on it you can see a reflection of the
stage lighting for the entire shot.
>>> When Cathy brings a pot of coffee
into the dining room, you can see several bright studio lights reflected in
it throughout this scene, and you can also briefly see the reflection of
someone's arm moving about on it.
>>> At the children's party, when the
birds attack, you can see a child roll under the table with the cake and
other party snacks on it. The birthday cake swaps ends with the bowl of
drink a few shots later, with nobody re-arranging it.
>>> As Melanie starts off across the bay
we see the boat keeper watching her from the ladder. A few seconds ago there
were lobster traps piled all around and above the fence behind him.
>>> After Mitch runs to Annie and Cathy
there's a fake movable bird behind the real bird to the right of the swing.
It's gone when we see Mitch carry the little girl into the house.
>>> A blond boy in a light brown shirt is
attacked by a crow and goes from having no blood on his neck to having a lot
of blood smeared on his neck between shots.
>>> When Jessica Tandy walks into Mr.
Faucet's house everything is in perfect shape except a couple of broken cups,
and there's not a dead bird in sight.
>>> Melanie's car changes positions from
the time she parks near the front steps of the school. As Melanie walks out
of the school to sit by the monkey bars to when she runs back to the school,
and then when the children run out of the school.
>>> As they look across the bay at
Mitch's house, the store manager changes position between shots. He moves
closer to Melanie as he asks her if she wants him to order a boat for her.
>>> The signature on the card that
Melanie signs to Cathy in the close-up on the hood of the car is different
when she leaves it leaning on the birdcage at Mitch's house. The "Y" at the
end of her name is different on the two envelopes.
>>> As Melanie drives up the main street
of Bodega Bay a kid on a bike appears riding behind her between shots. He
wasn't there in the previous shot when they show her behind the steering
wheel and we can see back behind her car.
>>> As the school children are running
down the hill a white fence appears between shots in the background on the
right of the screen.
>>> In a close-up of Melanie in the phone
booth after a blue and white car crashes into the orange car look at the
left side of the screen. You'll see the stop sign that the blue and white
car just knocked over back up where it was seconds before.
>>> The windshield of a blue and white
car that crashes into a stop sign gets broken on the left side. In the next
shot as Melanie looks at it up close from the phone booth it's not broken.
>>> In two of the shots inside the cream
colored car right after Melanie blows the horn either wires or a visual
artifact from the superimposing process distinctly appear outside of the
rear right window.
>>> As Annie opens the door and finds the
dead bird on the floor, the background across the street changes from of a
very dark house with two lights on to a moonlit road between shots.
>>> As Mitch and Melanie walk down the
hill he's behind her and they're not touching. In the next shot he has his
left hand behind her.
>>> Some of the children that are running
in front of the superimposed background were never in the classroom. For
example the blonde girl in the blue and white sweater in the middle of the
second shot and the girl in the green sweater in the center of the third
shot were not there.
>>> When Lydia says to Melanie, "Do you
think Cathy's alright at the school?" the two pictures hanging above her
head disappear the next time we see her.
>>> When Melanie shows Annie the
nightgown she bought, there's a box directly behind Melanie's brandy glass.
Now it's silver, but before it was turquoise.
>>> As Melanie and Mitch walk down the
hill Annie and Cathy are standing in the middle of the yard with two other
children between them and the lounge chair. In the next shot as we see Lydia
carrying the cake, the two children disappear and Annie and Cathy have moved
to the left closer to the door.
>>> As Melanie, Mitch and Cathy get into
her car to leave the school, Annie's red mailbox can be seen out on the road
behind them. In the next shot of them inside the car driving away the post
is there but the red mailbox is not on it.
>>> In her room as Melanie walks past the
mirror the first time there is nothing on the upper wooden ledge in front of
the glass. As she walks back from the window there's plenty of stuff there.
>>> As Lydia looks at Melanie and Mitch
walking down the hill, the large piece of molding in the corner between the
door and window disappears between shots.
>>> After finding Mr. Faucet's body,
Lydia gets back in her truck through the passenger side door. Notice that
the window is rolled up and the side vent window is shut tight. Seconds
later we see her inside the truck with the window rolled down and the vent
window tilted open.
>>> As Annie says to the students, "All
right children now quiet," her lips do not match what she says. This
continues before she says, "Miss Daniels" and her lips move and nothing
comes out.
>>> The book on the table to the left of
Melanie's brandy glass has been made to look as though someone has been
reading it. When we first see it the cover is closed now the cover looks as
though it's been thumbed through even though no one touched it.
>>> After Melanie signs the card to Cathy
she never puts her left glove back on. We're able to see her drive down
uninterrupted to the boat and she never puts it on, but when she walks out
of the car to the boat it's back on.
>>> After Mitch ties the shutter closed
both sides of the window look identical with each shudder being seen through
the window, but as he walks back into the living room just before the lights
go out the left shutter is the same and the right shutter is black.
>>> As Lydia looks through the window of
Mr. Faucet's kitchen there is a distinct pattern on the wall to her left. As
she comes through the door the pattern on the wall is different and she's in
a different room.
>>> The lamp over the dining room table,
when Melanie brings Cathy back from the bathroom, is not this same lamp that
was there as they were listening to the television report. Before it had a
glass bottom and now the entire bottom is made of metal.
>>> As Lydia carries the birthday cake
out from the house the position of the vine growing on the pole on the right
jumps from right to left between shots.
>>> As Melanie runs to Annie in the
classroom and says, "Close that door quickly," all the children's jackets
and sweaters and everything on the bench below changes between shots.
>>> At Mr. Faucet's house, both doors
that Lydia walks through are blue but after she walks in the door is white.
>>> After Mitch rescues Melanie from the
phone booth he places her to the left of the front door of the restaurant as
he reaches to open it. In the next shot their positions change and she is in
front of the door going into restaurant.
>>> As Melanie talks about renting the
apartment Annie's hair changes slightly between shots. Two little pieces of
hair stick out right by her left ear that weren't there in the previous shot
when she opens the door. Annie's hair changes in other consecutive shots
throughout the film.
>>> As they go up to the restaurant to
get help Melanie says, "I had a booster before I went abroad last May" and
the background changes abruptly between shots.
>>> When we first see the table with the
food on it the sandwiches in the middle are piled up in interlocking stacks
of three with one more pile of three or four sandwiches rising in the center.
When we see the sandwiches again up close as Mitch brings the little girl
into the house, they are neatly stacked above each other though not
interlocking as before and the middle pile is not there.
>>> After Melanie hangs up the phone she
sits and ponders whether to go to Cathy's party, on the desk to the left of
the phone is the cigarette lighter that Annie left there before after she
lit her cigarette. Next to it is a pack of cigarettes that she didn't leave
there before. If you look closely earlier as she takes the cigarette out of
the pack in the left pocket of her nightgown the lighter is in her right
hand, the cigarette in her left and the pack stays in her pocket.
>>> As Melanie stands in front of the pet
shop and watches the birds flying, more time passes than the two seconds
implied. The kittens in the right window go from playing to sleeping between
shots and a grey kitten appears in the window that wasn't there before.
>>> At the party Melanie grabs a girl
from the birds, but when they all run into the house Mitch is now carrying
the same girl.
>>> When Melanie is walking up to the
counter in the bird shop she has a black purse in her hands. In one shot she
is walking to the counter with her purse in her hands, but in the following
shot, her purse is laying on the counter and is now taking off her gloves.
>>> Mitch puts the glass of brandy up to
Melanie's lips and we see the brandy touch her upper lip and slosh around
but then as he pulls it back there's not a trace of liquid on her lips.
>>> In the long shot as Lydia drives up
to Mr. Faucet's farm the small structure in front of the building on the far
right has four windows. As she parks the truck, we see that structure only
has two windows.
>>> In the scene with the policeman,
Melanie suggests that she should stay for the night. Look closely at the
mantle above the fireplace to in the right of the picture there is a jar
with something sticking out of it. In the previous shot this jar is empty.
>>> Mitch carries Annie's body into her
house through the front door, which he doesn't close behind him. In the next
shot as he leaves the house it's been closed and he has to open it before he
walks out.
>>> When we saw the phone booth earlier
in the movie it was sitting on rock now as Melanie runs inside it for
protection from the bird attack it's sitting on asphalt.
>>> As Melanie and Mitch look at Annie's
body more time elapses then we are led to believe. There's a car parked on
the road directly behind them and there are no cuts in the time line of the
movie, but ten seconds later we see that spot again and the car is gone.
>>> As Mitch throws logs onto the fire we
see the couch behind him and no one is there. In the next shot Melanie
appears sitting on the pillows on the edge of the couch.
>>> As everyone runs out of the
restaurant, the bushes on the left of the building that were there before
are gone.
>>> When Mitch unwraps the cotton to put
peroxide on Melanie's cut, the ashtray on the table is empty. Mitch never
lets the piece of cotton out of his fingers until he has Melanie hold it on
her head, and no one else touches the cotton on the table, yet near the end
of the scene another used piece of cotton appears in the ashtray.
>>> A guy in the blue and white car that
comes crashing towards Melanie in the phone booth throws a bird out of his
driver side window. In the next shot as he fends off several other birds the
window is shut. Then when he crashes into the orange car, it's open again.
>>> During the bird attack Melanie
crushes the shade on the lamp in the corner. Several shots later it looks
almost like new.
>>> Earlier when the birds come out of
the fireplace Mitch puts his plate of food down on the table in front of him.
Later when he turns the table over, the plate of food is not there.
>>> After the gull hits her in the head,
Melanie says to Mitch, "Yes, I think so," but her mouth does not go along
with what she's saying.
>>> As Melanie speaks to the pet shop
cashier she holds her head to the left. In the next shot she's looking
straight at the cashier.
>>> As Melanie drives up to have dinner
at Mitch's the reflection of the cameraman on the inside of the window can
be seen moving in the upper left hand portion of the screen.
>>> As Melanie places the card for Cathy
on the bird cage one bird appears on the lower perch that wasn't there
before. In the next shot it disappears again.
>>> They use a different overdubbed tone
for the bell on the door of the general store when the manager opens it.
Before as Melanie walked into the store we heard the real sound.
>>> As Melanie opens Mitch's front door,
her pocketbook is strapped around her wrist. In the next shot, as she comes
through the door, the pocketbook is up around her forearm.
>>> As Melanie gets back into the boat
she places her pocketbook in the back with the latch facing her. In the next
shot as she watches Mitch on the shore the pocketbook is reversed and it
stays that way until she gets out of the boat after being hit by the gull.
>>> As Annie goes across the room to get
an ashtray, you can see that the next room is pitch black. In a previous
shot when she went to get the brandy it was lit up and she never touched a
light switch.
>>> The aerial shot of the fire is wrong.
The two cars parked across from the exploding orange car are green on the
left and white on the right. In the aerial shot they're both black.
>>> As Mitch runs to get the hammer and
nails for the front door notice the top leaf of the fern plant to his left.
It gets rearranged in the next shot, as Melanie watches him, with one fern
sticking out from the middle that wasn't there before.
>>> The top of the bird cage that Melanie
brings to Mitch's apartment has 24 rungs but when we see it again on the
floorboard of Melanie's car it has only 12 rungs.
>>> As Melanie approaches the cashier,
there are several birds up high in the cage directly behind the cash
register that aren't there in the next shot.
>>> After Melanie walks into Mitch's
house and puts the cage down we see that there are no birds either on the
perches or in the bottom of the cage.
>>> As Melanie starts off across the Bay,
we see two boats and a red building to the left of the matte drawing that
weren't there when she approached the boat keeper.
>>> Lydia puts her plate of food on the
table in front of her as she gets up. She never touches it again, but later
on in the bird attack the plate of food has been moved onto the couch near
Melanie's plate in front of the red pillow.
>>> When Melanie pulls up to the school
to check on Cathy we hear voices of the children singing inside and a crew
member's reflection is seen moving in the car door as she opens it.
>>> Just before the lights blowout Mitch
comes back into living room and there is a red ottoman to the right of the
green chair that Lydia and Cathy are sitting in. A few moments before, all
three of them just walked through that spot when they were hiding by the
bookcase and it wasn't there.
>>> When Melanie first walks into the
classroom she sees five rows of students. Later when the students are about
to leave there are only four rows of students, now ending with the boy in
the plaid shirt (closest to the camera), in the front. The row on the left
has been removed so the camera can pan from left to right in the side shot.
>>> As Melanie runs into the phone booth
from the restaurant the four poles that were around it when Mitch walks her
to the restaurant after the gull attack have disappeared.
>>> Melanie has no problem taking the
letter for Mitch out of her pocketbook as she places it on top of the bird
cage. The crew put adhesive tape on the back of it, so she can push on the
letter with her thumb to keep it in place for the close-up.
>>> When Annie gets up and says, " I
think I'll have some of that" her cigarette is half gone with a long ash on
it. In the next shot as she fiddles with the brandy bottle her cigarette is
brand new.
>>> A large equipment shadow can be seen
on Melanie and Mitch as they stop to look at the people in the restaurant
hiding in the corner.
>>> When Mitch picks up the mirror his
right hand grabs one of the umbrellas hanging on the right of the mirror. It
in the next shot the umbrella has disappeared.
>>> As Melanie parks in front of the
general store stage lighting and the reflection of a crew member can be seen
in her car door as she opens it.
>>> As Melanie approaches Doodles Weaver
to get her boat there are no lobster traps where he is standing. Two shots
later she climbs down the ladder and there are two traps to the right of the
ladder.
>>> Melanie is only in Mitch's house for
one minute, but the tide has already gone out enough to beach the other boat
tied to the dock.
>>> As Melanie signs the card to Cathy
there's a guy in the phone booth to the left of the Bodega Bay bar who's not
there in the next shot.
>>> As she sits and listens to Melanie
talk to Mitch on the phone Annie's right hand changes positions between
shots. She starts to move it up, then in the next shot it's already leaning
on her left hand.
>>> As the birds sit on the monkey bars
outside the school we hear the sound of many birds flapping their wings for
several seconds before any take off.
>>> As Melanie walks into Annie's
apartment we see the front door behind here to the left. Before the door had
a shade on top of it, this door is different and doesn't have a shade or a
space for it between the curtain and the window.
>>> Before Melanie starts off across the
bay we hear the boat keeper start the boat's engine. But this is only an
over-dub, the engine's not really running as there's no turbulence behind
the boat like in the next two shots.
>>> The overdub of Melanie playing piano
in the living room is the same volume when the scene changes to a different
room as Mitch and Lydia talk inside the kitchen.
>>> As Melanie approaches Mitch's dock, a
yellow pole extends from the far left side of the dock to the brown pail in
the front of the dock. In the next shot, as she walks on the dock, the pole
is gone.
>>> As they talk Annie walks over to sit
behind her desk and we see a quick shot of her hallway. Look closely at the
mirror hanging on the far wall and you can see the quick reflection of the
studio equipment in it.
>>> When they show the perspective of
being in Melanie's driver's seat looking out the windshield we don't see
Melanie's legs as you would expect, but a mechanism that allows someone to
steer from the passenger seat so the camera has an unobstructed view of the
driver's seat.
>>> After finding Mr. Faucets body Lydia
gets back in her truck and you can see the reflection of a crewmember
wearing headphones in the lower right part of the windshield.
>>> At the end of the movie when they're
walking out of the house you hear a door open, but the doorway is empty -
it's just an open space, with no door.
>>> When Melanie asks Annie if she can
use her phone the reflection of a crew member behind her can be seen moving
in the window of the house across the street.
>>> When Mitch is closing the shutter
after the birds have started to fly into the window you can visibly see
blood on the shutter, yet when they switch cameras and he shuts the shutter
the blood is gone.
>>> The crew rigged the explosion to
start from under the car and not from the lit match which isn't thrown
anywhere near where the explosion originates.
>>> As Mitch hammers the mirrored cabinet
to the front door they overdub a second hammer sound over the actual sound
to make it more intense. If you listen closely they don't get them all right
and they miss the very first swing.
>>> After Melanie delivers the lovebirds to the Brenner home, the camera
follows her as she walks back along the jetty to her boat, with the dolly
track clearly visible.
>>> When Melanie and Mitch are together on top of the bluff at the
children's party, each person casts two sets of shadows.
>>> When Melanie is climbing upstairs we see her shadow on the wall, even
though the only light source is the flashlight she is using.
>>> Many times, the car is on the wrong side of the road.
>>> In some shots, the car being driven by Melanie has no gear shift. The
engine shifting sounds are obviously from a manual transmission, but she
never makes a shifting motion with her right arm.
>>> Just before the gas station explosion, gas is shown running into the
left rear tire of a red car. The next shot of that car, taken from a little
farther back, shows gas running near the tail of the car but the area around
the tire itself is completely dry.
>>> When the children are running from the school while being attacked, the
birds attacking them cast no shadows.
>>> After the seagull attacks Melanie on the boat, her hair appears
disarranged. The next shot shows her hair neatly arranged again.
>>> When Melanie brings Lydia some tea, while Lydia is in her bed, Lydia's
hair first looks disarranged. Then her hair is neatly arranged, the next
shot it is disarranged again.
>>> When Annie Hayworth is telling the students to quietly exit the school
and return to their homes, the speed of her voice and the movement of her
lips do not match.
>>> When Melanie enters Bodega bay school for first time, we can hear the
child singing even when they turn around to see Melanie, and are clearly not
moving their lips.
>>> When Melanie gets out of her car and approaches Mitch's front door when
she first arrives for dinner, she's wearing no glove on her right hand. In
the next shot she turns to greet the family approaching from the yard, and
is wearing both her beige gloves.
>>> When Melanie Daniels is driving the lovebirds to Bodega Bay you can hear
the car changing gears from a manual transmission. But the gear shift lever
is reflected on the floorboard of the car and has no hand on it and never
moves, and it appears to stay in neutral.
>>> When Melanie is driving to Bodega Bay, her car is heard accelerating,
but her foot is flat on the floor, not on the pedal.
>>> When Melanie is lying unconscious after the birds attack her, Mitch
gives her some brandy to 'alleviate' the pain. However, in no way should he
be giving her this because any liquids given to an unconscious person could
cause them to choke, and they should especially not be given any alcohol.
>>> When Mitch tries to close the window shutter as the birds attach, his
hand is extremely bloody. However once the window is closed, there is much
less blood showing.
>>> At the end of the movie when Mitch gets in Melanie's car to take it out
from the garage, he closes the window of the car. After a minute when he
gets of the car in front of the garage the window is open.
>>> When Melanie was driving her car to deliver the lovebirds, there's a
shot of the front of the car and the camera is reflected in the window.
>>> While in the car when the crows attack the school, Melanie's left hand
is by her head when she beeps the horn. In the next shot, her hand is on the
steering wheel while beeping the horn, the next shot her hand is by her head
again.
>>> In the phone booth, Melanie has her back on the phone. But in the next
shot, she is by the phone not front.
>>> After two birds break the glass on the phone booth, it appears that the
glass isn't shattered when Melanie is grabbed out of it.
>>> When the gull attacks Melanie, at the 24th minute, we see Mitch jumping
from the pontoon twice: once from Melanie's point of view, then a second
time from the pontoon. And Mitch's attitude is clearly not the same in the
two shots.
>>> There is an obvious synchronized backdrop used when Melanie is crossing
the bay in the little motor boat to see Mitch; same thing on the return trip.
>>> When Melanie slaps the hysterical woman in the restaurant, the close-up
of Melanie shows her using her right hand. However, the reverse shot of the
hysterical woman shows what would be Melanie's left hand.
>>> In the scene where Melanie comes to Annie's house to spend the night,
they hear a thud at the front door and open it to see what caused the noise
(a seagull had crashed into the door). In the first shot, where they open
the door, the view from the door is a house across the street. In the next
shot, where they are discussing the fact that there is a full moon that
night, the view from the door is rolling hills - no house.
>>> When Mitch carries Annie's body into her house, the front door is
already open. We cut back to Melanie and Kathy, then cut back to the front
of the house--where the door is shut. Mitch opens the door, walks out, and
shuts it behind him. Shutting the door behind him while carrying Annie's
body is not only impractical, but as the door swung outward, would be next
to impossible. |
|
| 1960 |
Psycho |
|
>>> Als Marion Crane ihre Sachen packt und die
Kamera auf das Bett zufährt, wo das Geld liegt, fällt der Schatten der
Kamera auf die Bettdecke.
>>> Als man den Stuhl im Obstkeller, auf dem die
Mutter sitzt, von hinten sieht, ist es ein Stuhl mit 4 Füßen, aber als die
Mumie berührt wird, dreht sie sich wie auf einem Drehstuhl.
>>> Marion (Janet Leigh) zerreißt einen
Zettel, auf dem sie etwas ausgerechnet hat. Sie wirft die Papierschnipsel in
die Toilette und man sieht ganz deutlich, dass alle Schnipsel in die
Toilette fallen. Als sich aber später Marion's Schwester Lila (Vera Miles)
in dem Badezimmer umsieht, findet sie einen der Schnipsel.
1. Wie schon gesagt, man hat gesehen, dass alle Schnipsel in der Toilette
gelandet sind.
2. Norman (Anthony Perkins) hätte besagten Schnipsel spätestens beim
Badezimmersäubern gefunden, als er alle Spuren beseitigt hat. Er musste ja
schließlich einen Mord vertuschen, also wird ihm sowas ja wohl nicht
entgangen sein.
>>> Norman hat sein "Spannerloch" mit
einem Bild verdeckt. Er hebt es leicht an und
nimmt es dann ab. Es scheint also an einem Nagel zu hängen. Anschließend ist
jedoch kein Nagel zu sehen.
>>> When Marion is driving her car
through the night, she keeps looking at her speedometer. You can clearly see
that the gear shift lever is in "park" as she is driving.
>>> When Norman picks up Marion's body to
carry it to his trunk, a bra is visible through the shower curtain. Gus Van
Sant included this goof in his 1998 remake.
>>> When Janet Leigh is shown lying dead
on the floor of the shower, there is a close-up of her open eye. The pupil
is contracted to a pinpoint (obviously due to the bright lighting) where it
should have been dilated. After the film was released, Hitchcock heard from
several ophthalmologists who pointed this out and suggested he use
belladonna eyedrops in the eyes of "dead" people in future films, as the
chemical prevents the pupils from contracting.
>>> When Marion and Norman are talking
after he has brought in some sandwiches, Marion tears the same piece of
bread 3 times on different occasions.
>>> While Janet Leigh is being stabbed to
death by Mother, as Janet turns around in the shower, it is possible to see
part of the moleskin that Janet wore for the scene for a split second.
>>> When Marion arrives at the car
dealership, the salesman sees her and starts walking towards her. If you
look carefully, there is a wire trailing out his trouser leg, most likely
for a hidden mic.
>>> Mother comes out of her room and
slashes Arbogast with a knife. After he falls down the stairs, Mother comes
down and stabs him again. But when she does this, her knife has no blood on
it.
>>> In the scene where Marion's boyfriend
and sister visit the Sheriff and his wife at home, there is a camera shot
where you can see that living room background scenery ends and there is no
ceiling.
>>> At the end of the film in the
Sheriff's office, you can see a wall calendar with the date on 17. The film
started on December 11th - Marion absconds with the money on the same day.
She slept the first night in her car, then drove all day Saturday before
arriving later that night at Bates motel, she was killed the same night.
When Arbogast arrives we learn that Marion has been missing for one week, it
is now Saturday, Sam and Lila visit the motel to look for Arbogast, (who by
now is dead) and they go to visit Sheriff Chambers later that same evening.
They meet the Sheriff the following Sunday morning outside the church, it is
on the same day that Norman is captured and taken into custody, now the date
on the wall calendar should have shown 20 and not 17, the story has lasted
for a total of nine days and not six days.
>>> The towel Norman takes off the wall
to dry the tub with is white, when he puts it on the back of the toilet it
is dark in color and when he throws it into the bucket it is white again.
>>> When Marion steps into the shower, we
can hear (not see) her unwrap a bar of soap and throw the wrapper on the
floor of the shower. But when Norman is cleaning the bathtub, after Marion
is killed, the wrapper is no where in sight. (Timecode available)
>>> Norman brings a tray of food to
Marion, when she says "So long as you've fixed supper we may as well eat it,"
watch how her folded arms change position from hands tucked underneath, to
hands on top of her arms.
>>> When Marion arrives at the Bates
motel, she sounds the car horn for the first time, the windscreen wipers are
switched on. She gets out of the car, looks towards the old house, then goes
back to the car, as she sounds the horn for the second time the windscreen
wipers are now switched off.
>>> When Marion first gets ready to get
in the shower, the camera is panning back over the bed to show the newspaper
with the cash wrapped up in it. As the camera pans back, one can clearly see
the camera's shadow on the bed as it pans back.
>>> When Norman is parking Marion's car,
he does so by reversing with right hand lock. But when he drives off, he
does so with left hand lock without having turned the steering wheel.
>>> After Marion has been murdered there
is a close-up of her face. If you look down to her neck you can see her
pulse.
>>> When Marion is buying another car at
the dealership, in the background you can see the same extras walking in
different directions on the sidewalk.
>>> When Norman carries Marion's dead
body out to the boot of the car, the water on Marion's bonnet changes
between shots. In some shots there is water, sometimes there is no water.
>>> After Marion's sister and boyfriend
look through the Number 1 bathroom and find the ring on the toilet, they
turn off the light. On the wall behind them you can make out a square beam
of light, but no other lights are on in the cabin.
>>> In the shower scene, Marion Crane's
palm looks water wrinkled as if she's been in the shower for quite a long
time even though she was only in for a few moments before Norman stabs her.
Also, when Norman drags her out of the bathroom, Marion's legs are stiff and
together and she has her toes pointed.
>>> As the camera zooms into the hotel
window, you can see a shadow on the blinds. But in the next shot, the shadow
is now longer (even though it's supposed to be in real time).
>>> After seeing Marion's dead body in
the bathroom, Norman accidentally knocks down a framed picture of a bird (with
the picture facing up and it is a few inches away from the wall). But when
Norman is spreading the shower curtain on the floor, the picture has changed
position (with the picture now facing down and it is against the wall).
>>> In the scene after Janet Leigh is
killed Norman goes into Cabin one and starts mopping. He puts the mop in
front of the bed for a second. Through the mirror you can see the mop fall
when he put it down, but when he goes back to get it, the mop is up again.
>>> The state trooper asks Marian for her
"license," but not the registration. Then he looks at the car's plate and
verifies the number. But it would be on the registration, not on her license.
>>> When Marion steps into the shower and
pulls the curtain shut, if you look closely, you can see a rubber bath mat
with holes in it. After this shot, the mat is not seen again (during the
murder or the clean-up).
>>> In the Bates Motel drawing room with Norman, Marion tears the
same piece of bread three times down the middle.
>>> As Marion approaches the restroom at California Charlie's used
car lot, the door hinges on the left with the doorknob on the right and has
dark (painted?) glass in the upper half. In the interior shot, the hinges
and knob are just the opposite and the door is a solid slab. In the exterior
shot as Marion exits the restroom, the door is solid with no glass, and
hinges on the right and latches on the left, consistent with the interior
view.
>>> At one point during Marion's night-flight from Phoenix toward
Fairvale in her black 1956 Ford, there is a point-of-view shot over the hood
of the white 1957 Ford that she doesn't have yet. She gets the newer car
from California Charlie the following day.
>>> The hood of Marion's car is alternately wet and dry between
shots as Norman carries her body out to it.
>>> When the car salesman first moves towards Marion in the car
lot, his mic cable is visible, trailing out from his trouser leg.
>>> When Marion drives away from the police officer, the
unmistakable sound of a 1957 Ford starter can be heard, but she doesn't
reach for the key (which is left of the steering wheel on the dashboard), or
make any visible movement to use the shift lever.
>>> When driving, Marion grasps the steering wheel and, while going
straight, at times has the spoke of the wheel pointed to the right and at
times to the left.
>>> While driving in Bakersfield, no car dealership can be seen
through the windshield as Marion turns off a major road onto a wide, unlined
street. The next exterior shot shows her car turning off a four-lane, lined
street into California Charlie's used car lot.
>>> In the shower, Marion's hand changes from thumb down to thumb
up when she grabs the shower curtain and then pulls it down
>>> The shadow of the camera falls on the lady examining the
pesticide can in Sam's hardware store.
>>> When the police officer backs in behind Marion's car on
shoulder of the highway, no tire tracks from his vehicle are visible in the
soft dirt.
>>> At the car dealership, the same extras (people on the sidewalks)
are seen repeatedly, walking in different directions
>>> In the hotel at the start of the film, Sam sits with his arms
outstretched. In the close-up of Sam, the towel has moved across to his
right though he hasn't yet moved his arms.
>>> When Norman is making his way from the house to the hotel
office to greet Marion, it is pouring rain outside. However, in the next
shot when he's in the hotel office his suit is completely dry.
>>> When Marion gets in the shower, she unwraps a bar of soap and
drops the wrapper in the tub. When Norman is cleaning up the tub, no wrapper
is ever seen.
>>> When Marion first gets out of her car and meets the salesman at
the used car dealership, a crewmember is reflected in the car door. Part way
through the shot, he suddenly crouches down.
>>> In the very beginning of Psycho, we are given a date of
December 11th, mid-afternoon in Phoenix, Arizona. However, throughout the
Phoenix sequence we see all of the characters acting as if it is sweltering
hot outside. Marion's boss even has the air conditioning going in his office.
Anyone familiar with Phoenix in December would know that it is one of the
coldest months there.
>>> When Marion is driving to the motel in the rain, the camera
zooms in on the Bates Motel sign and just to the right you can see a spot
light on a stand that illuminates the motel.
>>> When Marion is lying on the floor with the ECU zoom out on her
eye, her eye twitches a few seconds before the ending of the shot.
>>> In the third scene, after the hotel and the office -- while
Marion is in her apartment, dressing up before going away with the money she
stole from her boss --, you can first see her in the background putting on
her dress, with the bed down in the forefront. Then the camera closes in on
the envelop containing the partially visible money bills. Just before the
camera stops on a close up of the envelop, a shadow is briefly seen on the
right hand side, on the bed cover. This is ONLY visible in the VHS versions
on the film -- not in the newer letterbox versions on DVD, where the upper
and lower parts of the frame were cropped a little.
>>> When Lila and Sam are walking from their motel room to the
office, the reflection of a crew member can be seen in the window between
rooms 1 and 2.
>>> After Detective Milton Arbogast has fallen down the stairs and
is being stabbed repeatedly, each time the knife comes up we can see no
blood on it. |
|
| 1959 |
North by Northwest/Der unsichtbare Dritte |
|
>>> In the shooting scene in the Mount
Rushmore cafe, a boy in the background puts his fingers in his ears, because
he knows the gun is about to be shot.
>>> When in James Mason's house in South
Dakota, Cary Grant writes a message to Eva Marie Saint on a matchbook from
which several matches are missing. When Ms. Saint subsequently reads the
message the matchbook is full.
>>> In the scene in which Cary Grant is
attacked by the crop duster, he is supposed to be between Chicago and
Indianapolis. Unfortunately, northwest Indiana looks nothing like this. The
scene in the movie has miles and miles of treeless landscape. Even in the
flattest farmlands of Indiana, there are many visible groves of trees.
>>> Cary Grant is crouching in his bunk
bed in the train. The lights of the studio get reflected on his broken
sunglasses when he shows them to Eve.
>>> When the plane hits the gas truck and
it catches on fire, instead of getting out on the passenger side, the
passenger crawls out the driver's side.
>>> In the scene where Cary Grant is
hanging off Mount Rushmore, and Eva Marie Saint falls and grabs Cary's back
pocket, she rips it but in the next scene the pants are un-ripped.
>>> In Eva Marie Saint's hotel room,
after the crop-dusting, Cary Grant attempts to copy a note she has removed
from a pad, by scratching with a pencil point - horizontally. In the
close-up of the note, it has been scratched vertically.
>>> The first scene that they show of the
train going up the Hudson River is wrong. The hills in the background are
much further up the river past Croton NY. When they are eating the train is
back down near the wider part of the Hudson around Tarrytown NY.
>>> In the last scene before Chicago the
train is going through the tunnel at Breakneck Pass north of Cold Spring NY.
When they're going back home at the end of the movie theoretically they
should be going the same way but they're not. The final tunnel shot in North
by Northwest is the Southern Pacific railroad tunnel between Santa Susana
and Chatsworth California.
>>> In the very first scene when the
train pulls out of Grand Central Station you can see that the sun is setting.
Then when they sit down to eat it's the middle of the day again.
>>> When Eva Marie Saint grabs the statue
from James Mason and bolts, the spies chase after her. They had no way of
knowing she would do such a thing, and yet they are suddenly equipped with
long, heavy-duty flashlights.
>>> When Eve is being led out to the
airplane, she bolts when two shots are fired from inside the house (presumably
Anna firing at Thornhill, not realizing that the gun was loaded with blanks).
Moments later, she jumps into a car driven by Thornhill, and they escape
together. There is no way Thornhill could have gotten there that fast, given
that he was in the house only seconds earlier.
>>> While Thornhill and his mother are
investigating Kaplan's hotel room, he decides to try on one of the man's
suits from the closet to see if he and Kaplan are similar in stature. He
tries on a navy or dark colored suit coat and then holds the pants up
against himself to check the length. In the close up of the trousers, they
are now a light gray in color. The camera returns to a full shot and, once
again, he has the darker trousers in his hands. You can also see the light
gray suit in the closet behind him.
>>> Near the beginning of the film, as
Thornton has arrived at The Plaza and is opening the door of the taxi to
exit it; visible through the rear window is a red and white Ford taxi,
parked behind Thornton's taxi. Instantaneously, in the next shot taken from
the sidewalk, he is shown completing his exit from the cab. Now however,
there is a light colored Dodge taxi cab parked directly behind them.
>>> The villains try to kill Cary Grant
by getting him drunk and sending him off a cliff in a white Mercedes. He
manages to get back on the road and they follow him in a Cadillac limousine.
Cary passes a parked police car which gives chase. He brakes to avoid a
bicyclist and the police car rear-ends the Mercedes. Immediately a blue 1941
Ford rear-ends the police car. Where did it come from? It would have to have
been ahead of the Cadillac and very close to the police car to do so, but it
doesn't appear until the moment of impact.
>>> Thornhill & the "Professor" have a
chat on the airport tarmack, in which it's revealed to Thornhill that Eve is
a secret agent and in danger. At that moment the camera dollies in on
Thornhill for dramatic effect. As it does, the distant airplane in the
background gets closer very nearly as fast as does actor Cary Grant,
revealing that the background in this scene is, in fact, a rear projection
on a screen just beyond the actor.
>>> In New York, a newspaper headline
reads, MANHUNT ON FOR UN KILLER, with a smaller headline below reading
"Nixon promises West will remain in Berlin". The next night Eva Marie Saint
reads the crop-duster plane story in the Chicago Sun-Times. Since the
Sun-Times was a morning paper and the accident occurred in the afternoon,
she must have been reading the following morning's edition. But a smaller
headline underneath carries the same story: "Nixon promises West will remain
in Berlin"; two days later, it's old news.
>>> As Thornhill backs away from murdered
Townsend, the knife in his hand changes from point down to point up.
>>> When the plane crashes into the truck,
the bystanders walking towards the scene have shadows, which change angles
as you see the next shot. They took them both in the morning and the
afternoon.
>>> While Roger and Eve converse before
dinner on the train, Roger's glass mysteriously changes places several times.
When shot from behind, he's holding the glass; from the front, it's on the
table.
>>> Near the end of the movie when Cary
Grant says, "Come along Mrs. Thornhill." If you read lips he's actually
saying, "That's it."
>>> When Cary Grant arrives at the hotel
in Chicago, he sees Eva Marie Saint enter an elevator. By looking at the
indicator light he sees that she has gotten off on the fourth floor. He
would have had to have binoculars to see the elevator indicator light from
where he was standing.
>>> At Prairie Stop 21, after the second
man arrives, shots on Thornhill show that his left arm is bent (the sleeve
is folded), but the wide shot on both of them shows his arms at his sides.
>>> When Thornhill and Kendall reunite
after the shooting, they are obviously on a soundstage and not on location
in the wilderness. There is absolutely no background noise, which is
impossible in the outdoors: leaves rustling, birds calling, water trickling,
wind gusting, etc. prevent the complete silence depicted by the movie. The
quality of the actors' voices also sounds like indoors rather than an open
space.
Mistake Continuity: When Thornhill is talking to the maid in Kaplan's hotel
room, right after she identifies him as Kaplan, his arm changes from bent
over his stomach to straight at his side. (Timecode available)
votemap
>>> Thornhill and his mother go to
Kaplan's hotel room, room 796, to check the place out. There are two
telephones in the room and both phones have old-fashioned non-coil cords
connecting the phone and the handset. But when Thornhill rings the buzzer to
summon the maid you can see that the phone suddenly has a more modern coil
handset cord.
>>> The date shown on the newspaper after
Cary Grant is accused of stabbing the diplomat at the U.N. is Nov. 25, 1958.
The subsequent outdoor scenes clearly show leaves on the trees and people
dressed for warmer weather.
>>> When Cary Grant writes a message on a
matchbook and Eve Marie Saint reads it, the number of lines in the message
changes. He writes 3 lines, she reads 4 lines.
>>> When Cary Grant's character, Roger
Thornhill arrives at the UN building in search of George Kaplan we see his
shadow fall onto the door of the cab, as if the sun is behind him. But when
you look at the pedestrians on the sidewalk, their shadow falls in the
opposite direction. Simple mistake to make when using 3 point lighting in a
studio environment to produce a rear projection process shot.
>>> When Cary Grant and his film-mother
enter the elevator at the Plaza this is filmed through a glass-door and you
can see the reflection of a crewmember in a white shirt who is crouching
below or next to the camera.
>>> Cary Grant arrives at the spies'
house in Rapid City by taxi. Yet when he and Eva escape, they suddenly have
a car at their disposal.
>>> Before the famous attack by a crop
spraying aircraft, Cary Grant is set down in the middle of nowhere from a
Greyhound Scenicruiser. Another bus, a Flxible BR-29, also stops briefly.
The soundtrack of the Scenicruiser's engine is re-used for the Flxible.
>>> Cary Grant, running through Grand
Central Station after fleeing from the UN Building, has brown shoes, then
black, then brown.
>>> His suit changes colour as he is
running from the aeroplane. First blue, then brown, then back to blue.
>>> The top and back of Mount Rushmore
looks nothing like they portray it in the final scenes of the film. This is
a mountain, and they would need climbing equipment to get to the top of the
mountain. Also there are no trees at the top, and the is a vault at the top
of the mountain, behind the monuments. This vault was originally planned to
be used as a museum, but Congress withdrew funding because of World War II,
and the museum was never completed.
>>> Cary Grant steals a redcap's uniform
while he was sleeping, implying that the redcap had been on the overnight
run. Redcaps didn't ride the trains; they worked in the stations.
>>> When Eva Marie Saint is going out to
the aeroplane near the end of the film, it is dark as they walk away from
the house, but by the time they reach the plane it is suddenly daylight.
>>> In the Chicago P.D. patrol car after Thornhill's arrest at the auction
house, the cop on Thornhill's right forgets to lean as they simulate a turn.
Cary Grant can be seen giving the errant actor a poke in the arm.
>>> Position of the wine glass during the dinner on the train.
>>> Escaping from two thugs, Thornhill dashes out of the Plaza, grabs a cab,
and it drives off. The thugs get into the next cab and go after him. From
inside his cab, Thornhill then looks back at the hotel but the thug's cab is
not there. It should be just pulling away from the curb.
>>> When the crop-duster plane hits the tanker truck, the truck's shadow on
the road extends several feet across the center dashed white line. In the
next shot, the shadow reaches only a few inches across the white line,
without the truck having moved at all.
>>> The angle of the driver's side windshield wiper on the tanker truck (during
the shot when the truck's hit by the crop-duster plane) is different from
the angle in the next shot - even though the wipers aren't turned on.
>>> Many backdrop tops and light reflections.
>>> Wobbling trees as the ambulance passes.
>>> Inconsistent shadows during the crop-dusting scene.
>>> During the climactic Mt. Rushmore scene at the end of the film, the top
of the mountain set, and equipment, are clearly visible for a number of
seconds.
>>> Following the crop dust scene, Roger goes to Eve's hotel room. She makes
drinks for them. His is "scotch, water, no ice." She makes 2 drinks, putting
ice in hers - which is on her right. When she finishes, she picks the one
with the ice (hers) up with her right hand, and Roger's with her left. She
then turns and walks toward Roger. She hands him his drink with her right
hand. Hers, with the ice, is in her left hand.
>>> At the Chicago station when Eva tells Thornhill to take a bus to meet
Kaplan, in the long shot with the column behind them, the boom mike is
clearly visible wobbling above.
>>> After Thornhill approached and conversed with the man on the rural road,
the bus stops, picks up the man abruptly without pausing to see if Thornhill
also wants to board. Slams the door in his face and departs as if the driver
assumes instantly that Thornhill is not a customer.
>>> After Eve leaves her room at the Ambassador Hotel, Thornhill emerges
from the bathroom, where he has been pretending to take a shower, and
notices a notepad on the night stand. He picks up a pencil and uses the old
"rub a pencil over the impression to reveal the note that was written on the
sheet above it" trick. He begins rubbing using a horizontal motion form
left-to-right, however when the camera switches to an extreme close-up, the
pencil is being used in a vertical up-and-down motion.
>>> The little boy wasn't looking at Eve when she drew the gun, hence he
shouldn't have known to put his fingers in his ears.
>>> According to Eva Marie Saint, Cary Grant loved clothes and didn't want
to see the blue suit from the hotel scene in Chicago trashed from crawling
round in the dirt to avoid the crop duster. So, a different suit was used
for that scene (which happened to be a different color).
>>> Positioning of the three men and their wine-glasses seated in the
banquette when Thornhill joins them, prior to being escorted away by the
henchmen near the start of the film.
>>> When Thornhill and his mother are changing elevators you can see a crew
member bend over in the reflection on a pane of glass.
>>> When Vandamm's henchmen put the drunken Thornhill into his car,
intending him to drive over the cliff, their heads disappear, as the footage
of the actors protrudes into the matte cliff background.
>>> Thornhill is taken from Mt. Rushmore in an ambulance with a
hatchback-style rear gate, which is the correct rear door for an ambulance
conversion of a station wagon. When he arrives in the forest to meet Eve, he
emerges from a station wagon with a standard lower tailgate and upper hatch
- not an ambulance.
>>> Thornhill's hands jump around on Eve's hair and shoulders between shots
in her train car.
>>> When Thornhill is writing the message on the matchbook, it matchbook is
approx. half full with the matches concentrated in the middle of the book.
When Eve opens the matchbook below, the matchbook is full of matches.
>>> When Thornhill and his secretary are in a cab in front of the Plaza
Hotel, a 1958 Ford cab is parked behind them. But when Thornhill exits the
taxi, the car behind them has changed to a 1957 Dodge.
>>> Eve's line "I never make love on an empty stomach" is overdubbed with "I
never discuss love on an empty stomach".
>>> Every indication is given throughout the film that the action takes
place in the summer - the trees in NYC are in full flower, ditto the foliage
at the Long Island estate, the Indiana cornfield landscape is scorched, etc.
- yet the newspaper which the Professor and his colleagues read recounting
the murder of Lester Townsend carries a late November date.
>>> In the opening scene when Thornhill is taking a cab to the Plaza hotel
with his secretary, the cab makes a U turn on Central Park South right in
the middle of heavy traffic. A NYC Cop can be seen holding up traffic and
then letting it pass as they pull in front of the hotel.
>>> In "George Kaplan's" room at the Plaza Hotel, we see a close-up shot of
Thornhill pressing the call button for the maid. Visible in this shot is a
telephone with a coiled cord. But in all other shots that show that phone,
it has a straight, non-coiled cord.
>>> As Thornhill walks along the 20th Century Limited at Grand Central
Terminal, he passes a car that's numbered 10006. But after he gets on the
train and looks out the window, we see on the adjacent track another New
York Central passenger car that also is number 10006. Two passenger cars of
the same railroad will never have the same number.
>>> As the plane crashes into the truck, wires are visible on the right-hand
side of the screen.
>>> When Thornhill is photographed at the United Nations with the knife in
his left hand, Thornhill holds a picture of Vandamm in his right hand. Later,
this incriminating photo of Thornhill is seen in the possession of the the
ticket seller, with Thornhill holding the knife in his left hand but with
his right hand empty.
>>> When Roger is kissing Eve in her train compartment, he removes his hands
from the back of her head twice.
>>> The Indiana cornfields are partly harvested, and partly not (it's
November) - but there is no evidence of stubble in any of the fields that
have no corn.
>>> When Thornhill is with his mother in Kaplan's hotel room, he says, "Ah,
well, look who's here... our friend who's assembling the General Assembly
this afternoon," instead of "addressing the General Assembly".
>>> When Thornhill runs out of the corn field dust covers his shoulders.
There is no dust when he falls under the truck.
>>> As Eve is being led to the plane with the house in the background, the
sky appears to be very dark, but when the angle shifts with the plane in the
background, the sky appears to be very bright.
>>> The first exterior shot of the train depicts a pink sunset. Yet, it is
broad daylight in the following dining-car scene.
>>> The airstrip at Vandamm's place clearly seems to be a gravel strip. Yet,
as the plane touches down, a brief tire screech is heard, as from a plane
setting down on a concrete or asphalt strip.
>>> Thornhill sees the car with Eve and the others arrive and stop on the
same level as him while he's on the observation deck outside the cafeteria
at Mt. Rushmore. The parking lot is actually a couple hundred feet below.
>>> At the lodge at Mount Rushmore, the professor enters the lodge only a
few moments ahead of Thornhill, yet the shadows on the building are
completely different.
>>> As Roger Thornhill and Eve Kendall are walking along the station
platform in Chicago, you can see one end of a locomotive, indicated by the
short, white horizontal lines. There is a cut to a close-up of Eve's face,
and a cut back to them walking again. After the second cut, the side of a
passenger car is seen instead of the locomotive.
>>> In the UN stabbing scene, Thornhill pulls the knife from Townsend's back
with the blade pointing down. When the camera cuts to a wider shot,
Thornhill is holding the knife upright.
>>> In older copies, Thornhill's taxi ride with his secretary is a bit too
revealing. At points, you are able to see blue sky above their heads while
they're still in the cab. Only their exit from the taxi appears to have been
shot using a full-length automobile. This mistake (as well as several others)
were apparently fixed when the movie was re-mastered for DVD.
>>> In the struggle on Mt. Rushmore, Eve slips and tears Roger's right back
pocket from his trousers. In later shots his trousers are intact.
>>> Roger writes the message on the matchbook in three lines. When it is
shown later, the message is written in four lines.
>>> When Thornhill is about to get out of the cab leaving his secretary
there, the cab behind is bright orange. After he gets out, the cab behind is
a different color and make of car.
>>> When Leonard loses his footing while climbing down Mt. Rushmore, the
long shots show him dangling in front of a side of the mountain entirely
carved with vertical lines. But in the close-up, his feet are shown dangling
in front of bare rock, with the carved lines ending well above his ankles.
>>> When Thornhill escapes from the Mt. Rushmore house and runs over to the
black Ford, he is shown opening the car door and just starting to get in
while on the soundtrack the sounds of the door being closed and the ignition
being turned on are heard.
>>> After the plane/truck incident, the shadows change by 180 degrees
between shots of the spectator group and Thornhill driving away with the
stolen car.
>>> As the drunken Roger is placed in the car by the kidnappers, waves can
clearly be seen crashing into a rocky coast line with a large drop to the
sea. The scene takes place in Glen Cove, New York, as evidenced by the
police car, but there is nowhere on Long Island that has a coastline like
this.
>>> When the Mercedes carrying Roger is balanced on the rocky cliff, the
left rear wheel is spinning in the air. Moments later, the car drives back
on to the road. In a rear wheel drive car from the 1950's, all of the torque
would be delivered to the free wheel, making it impossible for the car to
move without being pushed or pulled.
>>> After escaping from the Rapid City hospital, Thornhill takes a cab to
Vandamm's mountain retreat. How does he know where it is? He has never been
there. |
|
| 1958 |
Vertigo/Aus dem Reich der Toten |
|
>>> In the final scene, pieces of
Madeleine's hair-do come down in the struggle up the bell tower steps. At
the top of the tower, before she falls, her hair is in perfect shape again.
>>> At the end after Madeleine falls, the
camera pulls away from the church tower. You can see the shadow of the
camera.
>>> When Scottie follows Madeleine back
to his home and joins her at his porch, Scottie holds the banister on his
front porch as he climbs the steps & then moves his arm to his side twice.
>>> When Scottie (James Stewart) visits a
bookshop to question its owner, the book display in the shop's window
changes between the time he enters and exits the store.
>>> James Stewart sees Kim Novak entering
a flower shop by the back door. Watch the shadows on the ground: in the very
next shot, when Stewart follows Novak, the shadows are very different.
>>> At the point where Scottie is
following Madeleine in the side-street, she enters a building and he follows.
When he is inside, in one shot the light reflecting on the door window is
white and in the next it is green.
>>> How does it happen that
Madeleine/Judy is able to enter the McKittrick Hotel unnoticed by the
manager, and leave unnoticed by either Scottie or the manager? So far as I
could tell this was not explained by the fact we subsequently learn that she
was an actress posing as Madeleine, as there should in any case have been
someone in the room when they checked, and her car can't have got away on
its own.
>>> In the scene where Scottie is
reporting to Elster about his findings, there are ice cubes in their drinks,
but in subsequent close-ups, the ice cubes are not there.
>>> In the final scene in the belltower
you can see shadows from the surrounding trees. That's because this scene
was shot at 3 in the afternoon. They just used a filter to make it look like
it was night.
>>> When Mr. Elster is telling Scottie
that his wife's car showed she drove 94 miles on the speedometer, he should
have said odometer.
>>> The ice cubes in Gavin and Scottie's drinks disappear.
>>> The amount of sunlight/shadows in the alley behind the flower
shop as first Madeleine and then Scotty walk towards the door.
>>> The parked cars opposite the alley behind the flower shop
change with the camera's point of view.
>>> When Scottie initially chases Madeleine up the bell tower
stairs at Mission San Juan Bautista, a crew person's hand and forearm
appears from behind the stairs for a few seconds in the upward shot of
Madeleine, then disappears back behind the stairs as she passes by.
>>> As the camera moves away from Scottie standing at the edge of
the tower, the shadow of the camera can be seen for a split second on the
outer wall of the tower. On the Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection DVD, the
image is cropped so the shadow cannot be seen.
>>> The book display in the bookshop window changes between the
entering and exiting shots.
>>> Scotty and Judy drive through a grove of eucalyptus trees that
is located south of San Juan Bautista on the way there from San Francisco.
>>> In the scenes that follow Judy putting on the gray dress, the
headboard light on her bed disappears and reappears.
>>> When Scotty and Madeleine are on the coast, she's wearing a
white coat with a gauzy black scarf. The scarf is arranged differently in
different shots and sometimes is missing entirely.
>>> When they are talking outside Scotty's apartment, the same red/white
1955 Oldsmobile goes past several times (although it could be someone
looking for an address or a parking space).
>>> As Judy packs to run away, the breast sections on Madeleine's
gray suit in her closet are popped out in one shot and pushed in in another
>>> In Ernie's restaurant there are two famous profile shots of Kim
Novak; in the second shot however (shot later in production) there is
noticeably less background scenery visible.
>>> As Scotty turns into the flower shop alley, the wall to his
right has no windows. When he exits his car, windows have appeared.
>>> While Scotty is spying on Madeleine in the art museum, the
furniture and artwork in the gallery seen through the open doorway next to
Carlota's portrait is rearranged between shots.
>>> When Madeleine wakes up in Scottie's bed, there are two chairs
on either side of the doorway as Scottie exits his bedroom. When he
re-enters the bedroom, one chair is missing and the other has moved.
>>> Before and after Scottie slides off the roof and hangs onto the
gutter, there are two views of him shown 90 degrees apart, but in both cases
the background view remains the same.
>>> When Madeleine is in Scottie's apartment after he rescued her
from the bay, he offers her two cushions to sit on in front of the fireplace.
When he picks up the cushions, they are green. In the next shot, when the
cushions are shown hitting the floor, they are gold. When the cushions are
shown lying in front of the fireplace after Madeleine has fled, they are
green again.
>>> When the manager of the McKittrick Hotel is walking Scottie to
Madeleine's room, the door is cracked open. A close-up shows the door closed
and the manager proceeds to open it.
>>> When Scottie and Madeleine are talking on the beach, there is a
tree between them. Madeleine puts her left arm around the tree, but then,
without her having moved, she has her back to the tree.
>>> When Scottie gets out of his car in front of the hotel, his
window is down. In the continuing shot as he walks away from the car, the
window is closed.
>>> When Scottie (James Stewart) buys new clothes for Judy (Kim
Novak) at Ransohoff's, Novak is shown trying on a pair of shoes. Due to the
extremely low camera angle when Novak walks away from the camera, it's easy
to see that the shoes are not new- their soles are heavily scuffed.
>>> During the scenes in which the main characters are driving from
San Francisco to San Juan Baptista, the POV shot from the car shows that
they are driving on the left side of the road.
>>> When Madeleine arrives at Sottie's apartment to post a letter,
the establishing shot shows only a few bushes by the metal railings. However,
in the closer two shots, more bushes are can be seen against the railings.
>>> When Scotty takes Madeleine out of water her shoe is off. When
they have reached the pier Madeleine has both shoes again.
>>> Gavin Elster mentions that Carlotta Valdes was 26 when she
killed herself. However, her gravestone says that she lived from December 3
1831 to March 5 1857. That would make her 25, not 26.
>>> In the scene where Scottie is following Judy for the first time
back to the "Empire Hotel," now "York Hotel," the traffic flow on Sutter
Street (one-way) is heading toward downtown instead of away from it, as it
does in actuality. |
|
| 1956 |
The Wrong Man/Der falsche Mann |
|
>>> Manny walks in the corridor of the prison
carrying the pillow with nothing on it. When he is inside the cell a
cannikin appears on the pillow.
>>> As Rose is being led up the stairs of the mental treatment
facility, the shadow of someone's head appears in the bottom left corner
behind the lamp. It seems as though someone walked past a bulb. |
|
| 1956 |
The Man Who Knew Too Much/Der Mann, der zuviel wußte |
|
>>> Dr. McKenna is wearing a blue suit
and hat during the bus ride in the beginning of the movie and then again as
the family board the wagon and set out for their hotel. When the wagon
arrives at their hotel and everyone gets out, McKenna's suit and hat have
suddenly switched to light gray.
>>> Although the assassin and the
ambassador are seated in the same tier of boxes, the assassin's view of his
target through the opera glasses is from below and not from across.
>>> During the interrogation after the
Albert Hall assassination attempt, the telephone used is an obvious Western
Electric American-made phone instead of a British-manufactured telephone,
betraying the fact that the interiors for the movie were shot in Hollywood.
>>> In the scene where James Stewart told
Doris Day that he lied about the telephone call was from the hotel, Doris
gets excited and James struggles with her on the bed. During that scene, you
can see on the upper left corner a shadow of a microphone.
>>> Multiple errors with Bernard's
stabbing. 1. The knife changes type after he is stabbed. 2. He is stabbed in
the lower neck but the knife moves down into the middle of his back in later
scenes. 3. The knife moves from his back to the ground without any noise at
all. It's just there on the floor.
>>> When Drayton is teaching the assassin his musical cue, he twice puts the
needle down on the record about 10 seconds before the cymbal crash that is
to cover the assassin's shot. After the assassin leaves, he does it a third
time for his own pleasure. Once would be remarkable, twice astonishing,
three times all-but impossible.
>>> During the interrogation after the Albert Hall assassination attempt,
the telephone used is an obvious Western Electric American-made phone
instead of a British-manufactured telephone - betraying the fact that the
interiors for this picture were shot in Hollywood.
>>> After Dr. McKenna tells his wife Jo about Hank being missing, she begins
to fall asleep and the shadow of the boom mike falls on the wall behind Dr.
McKenna's head.
>>> When the McKennas are riding to their hotel in the horse-drawn wagon
after getting off the bus, the shadows are mismatched between the foreground
and the back-projected scene. In the foreground, the shadows are on the left
of the characters, as if the sun is on the right of the frame; in the
back-projection, the shadows are on the right of the cars, as if the sun is
on the left of the frame.
>>> In the climactic scene at the Albert Hall concert, when the cymbalist
stands, turns and grabs his cymbals, the timpanist beside him is playing,
but is clearly not hitting the drums. Also, the timpanist is not the same
person who was playing (correctly) during the title sequence.
>>> In Marrakech, when Dr. McKenna and Jo go to the police headquarters, he
sits behind the desk and she sits at the corner of the desk. In the next
shot they are sitting side by side.
>>> Prior to Dr. McKenna and Jo enter Ambrose Chapel, there is a white stain
on Dr. McKenna's left shoulder, apparently from the struggle at the
taxidermist. As soon as Dr. McKenna enters the chapel, the stain disappears,
then reappears after they take their place in the chapel.
>>> Although the assassin and the ambassador are seated in the same tier of
boxes, the assassin's view of his target through the opera glasses is from
below and not across.
>>> In the Albert Hall, as Jo's emotion wells up in her and she turns away
from the orchestra, a camera shadow passes over her dress.
>>> On their first morning in London, McKenna leaves a taxi and walks down a
quiet residential street and stops at the next corner. Four or five camera
shots were taken as he slowly walked down the street. In the first three or
four shots the shadow of the buildings along the block extended across the
sidewalk to about three feet into the street. But in the final scene at the
corner the shadows were gone.
>>> Ben climbs up the bell rope and out the top of the bell tower to escape
the chapel. A bell in such a small tower could not possibly be heavy enough
to counterbalance Ben's body weight. Therefore Ben would pull the bell to
its limit while climbing, and the bell would not ring repeatedly as he
climbs the rope. And when Ben pulls the rope taut so that he can rappel down
the roof, the bell rings twice more. |
|
| 1955 |
To Catch a Thief/Über den Dächern von Nizza |
|
>>> Keep an eye on the letter that Cary
Grant has with all of the names of the potential theft victims. 1) The way
it is folded changes from 3 folds to 2 and from up to sideways. 2) The suite
numbers are wrong , as seen when CG goes to Grace Kelly's, and it is
different from the list.
>>> In the hotel bedroom, during the
fireworks night, when Grace Kelly calls Cary Grant, "Robbie," his arm is
bent towards his chest, but in the immediate wide shot it's straight and he
then bends it.
>>> When Cary Grant swims to the floating
dock to speak with Danielle, the ladder attached to the dock is not covering
the L in hotel in a couple of shots.
>>> In the scene where Cary Grant and the
insurance agent are walking through the flower market, the girl in the
bright pink dress walks past them twice.
>>> The letter that H.H. Hughson gives to John Robie with the names
of jewelry owners is folded into thirds horizontally, but later at the beach,
when John Robie notices it has a wet thumb-print, the letter is folded in
half vertically. In addition, the Stevens' address block has changed from 3
lines to 4 lines. "Chambre 541" has moved from the 2nd line to a separate,
new 3rd line.
>>> When driving, John and Frances lean the wrong way when Frances
turns the wheel..
>>> In the police car chase of John Robie and Francie, John and
Francie lean in one direction going around turns, but the police repeatedly
lean in the opposite direction going around the same turns.
>>> When Danielle is taking John to the beach club to avoid the
police, they briefly stop the boat to discuss moving to South America.
During the conversation, Danielle waves her finger at John, but in the next
shot her arms are crossed.
>>> On the list of jewelry owners, the room number of Mrs. Jessie
Stevens is given as 541, but when John Robie accompanies Mrs. Stevens and
her daughter to their rooms, the numbers on their doors are 625 and 623
respectively.
>>> The note with the warning message on Carlton Hotel stationary
that John Robie receives at the hotel's front desk before going to the Beach
with Francie has the impression of a similar message on it, made when the
prop department was creating various notes for the director to select for
use in this scene.
>>> John says he'll leave his clothes with Danielle, but later,
when he is at the flower market, he's in the same clothes.
>>> When Hughson hands Robie the list of jewel owners, he hands it
to him with his right hand. But in the next shot the list is suddenly in his
left hand.
>>> When Robie and Hughson are walking at the flower market they
look back at a few men following them. As they do, a woman in a bright pink
dress is walking towards the two men behind them. But as they turn back, the
same woman (who should have been behind them) is walking towards Robie and
Hughson.
>>> When John is holding onto Danielle as she is hanging off the
roof during her confession scene, in shots looking up at him, John is
gripping Danielle's wrist overhanded with an ungloved hand and she has a
glove on (which is how he caught her as she fell). In shots looking down at
her, Danielle's ungloved hand is gripping John's gloved hand.
>>> When driving from the villa, before the picnic, the reflections
of the studio lights can be seen on the car. |
|
| 1955 |
The Trouble with Harry/Immer Ärger mit Harry |
|
>>> In the porch scene with the little
boy, keep an eye on the rabbit. It moves around on John Forsythe's lap
between cuts, even though it's supposed to be dead.
votemap
>>> Right at the end, Shirley MacLaine's
dress has a large spot that disappears in the following shot.
>>> In the second-to-last scene there is a large wet spot on Jennifer's
blouse. A few seconds later, the wet spot is completely gone.
>>> After he draws the Harry's feet, Sam puts the paper block under his left
arm with a white sheet on the outside. In the next shot the sheet on the
outside has many drawings in it.
>>> After Arnie discovers Harry's body in the bath tub, Harry's foot can be
seen twitching just as the door opens for the second time.
>>> Throughout the whole movie the audio\video is mismatched due to the fact
that parts of it were filmed in a local gym due to bad weather.
>>> When Sam and Jennifer are talking in Jennifer's house, the shadow of the
boom mike can be seen moving across the top of the doorway behind Sam.
>>> Sam's pants have a lot of paint/charcoal on them when he's in the store
but are relatively clean after he sketches Harry and speaks with the Captain. |
|
| 1954 |
Dial M for Murder/Bei Anruf Mord |
|
>>> Early in the film, Grace Kelly is
talking to Bob Cummings about their extra-marital relationship and blurts
out "Oh, Bob." even though Bob Cummings' character's name is "Mark Halliday."
>>> Just before Anthony Dawson is going
to be stabbed to death by Grace Kelly with a pair of scissors, you can see
for a very short moment that the scissors are already attached to his back.
>>> When Tony dials the first phone call in the movie, it's clear
from the sound and his finger movements that the fourth digit is smaller
than the third, perhaps a 4. But from the immediately following dialogue,
the number should be HAMpstead 7899, i.e. 426-7899.
>>> As Margot reaches for the scissors, a bright spot can be
glimpsed over Lesgate's shoulders: it's one end of what's meant to be the
same scissors, already sticking out of his back.
>>> During the trial the date of the murder is clearly stated as
September 26th, but when looking at Tony's checkbook, Halliday says that
March 26th was "the day before all this happened".
>>> When Chief Inspector Hubbard uses his penlight to illuminate
the telephone dial (and later to show the lock on the apartment door) the
area of light is shaped and moves like an off-screen spotlight (which it is).
>>> Margot's press cuttings are clearly blank on one side; cut out
of newspapers, they should have printing on both sides.
>>> The inspector makes a phone call from the flat, supposedly in
London. We hear a clearly American-accented voice on the other end say "operator".
It should have been an English voice, saying (in the 1950s), "Number, please."
>>> Early in the film, Margot calls Mark (Robert Cummings) "Bob".
>>> Margot supplies a drink to Mark picking up the bottle among
others on a console table next to the wall. Later, after she takes the
blackmail notes in the bedroom, she joins him behind the console table with
the bottles on it. After that the console table is back to the wall.
>>> After Margot kills Lesgate, her handbag remains open on the
table, making it easy to Tony puts in it the key which he took off the
Lesgate's pocket. Then the handbag appears closed between shots.
>>> The boom mike is reflected in garden doors above Tony's and
Inspector Hubbard's heads during the Inspector's first visit.
>>> While Tony is first meeting with Swann, he holds a cane in
front of him while seated. In some shots he rests his chin on top of the
cane; in other shots the cane is clearly far too short to reach his chin.
>>> As Wendice is getting ready to leave with Mark (Bob Cummings)
he closes the curtains behind the desk while discussing Margot's plans for
the evening. After a few minutes discussion at the other end of the room
during which he convinces her to stay in and work on his press clippings,
the camera follows him back to the desk area where the curtains are open
again and he closes them again before he and Mark depart.
>>> In a shot of the Queen Mary, a part of the wall holding the
backdrop is visible. |
|
| 1954 |
Rear Window/Das Fenster zum Hof |
|
>>> The drainpipe running down the
building where the Thorvalds live, the one between the living room windows
and the bedroom windows of the block, becomes at least 1 foot (10cms) wide
at least three times through the film, and changes to a gingery colour,
almost as if it has become a plank of wood standing against the wall. It
also has a pipe or something running into it in a couple of shots, just
above the Thorvalds' bedroom window, but as this would be the "dog" couple's
bedroom, there shouldn't be a pipe coming down from there. At other times
the drainpipe just looks like an ordinary drain pipe. Even though we are not
meant to be looking at anything but the activities through the windows, the drainpipe is very evident in many shots as the action frequently moves over
it into the adjacent rooms. (Visible in the remastered video version and
others.)
>>> There's an oscillating fan near the
ceiling that alternates between running and not running from one cut to
another in one scene.
>>> When a man carrying a big block of
ice passes by the sculptress's backyard, we see her cat sitting on a chair
next to her as she works on her "Hunger" sculpture. In one shot, the cat is
facing toward the man, and in the next, it is facing away him when it gets
up, turns around, and meows at him.
>>> When Jimmy Stewart is watching the
couple in the next building, the wine glass behind him alternates between
being almost full and almost empty in successive shots.
>>> After James Stewart's second massage,
he buttons once in the middle of his pyjama shirt. In the next shot the top
button appears buttoned as well.
>>> In the scene where Ms. Lonelyheart
brings home a younger man, she slaps him on the left side of his face, and
when he leaves and stands outside her door he rubs the right side as if it
hurts.
>>> When the nurse first visits Jefferies,
his hands are separated. They jump together in the next shot when she places
the thermometer in his mouth.
>>> James Stewart uses a camera flashgun
to defend himself by repeatedly temporarily blinding Thorvald in the closing
scene. The number of flashbulbs in the cardboard box drops by two between
cuts as Stewart wheels himself back away from Thorvald.
>>> In the shot of the helicopter
hovering above the apartment building, the blue screen technique is
needlessly revealed by the eratic and physically impossible movements of the
chopper. This could have been avoided if the camera shooting the aircraft
had been stationary. It appears, however, that it was a handheld shot.
>>> At the end of the movie, when Jimmy
Stewart is hanging in the window, we can see that
it's a stunt double.
>>> If you look carefully, you can see
that the apartments of Miss Lonelyheart and the Thorvalds appear to be
ridiculously small in depth.
>>> When Lisa places her slippers into her overnight case (while sitting on
Jeff's lap), they are tossed in, more to the side of the case. Later, when
the detective views the suitcase, the slippers are neatly placed and sitting
upright.
>>> When Jeff is getting back into the wheelchair after Stella has given him
a massage, his pajama top jumps from being unbuttoned to buttoned between
shots.
>>> When Jeff grabs the box of flashbulbs, all four can be seen in the box.
But when he backs up more, there are only two left.
>>> After Lisa sees Thorwald tie up the trunk, and the camera dollies
forward to a close up, there are creaks from the floorboards and footsteps
heard from the camera crew.
>>> In the first full pan of the apartment area (just before Lisa first
appears, about ten minutes into the film) in a top floor window, an arc
light visibly blows out.
>>> Lisa takes the binoculars away from Jeff and wraps the neck cord around
them before putting them on a small cupboard. When Jeff picks up the
binoculars later, the neck cord is no longer wrapped around them.
>>> The amount of Brandy in the detective's glass increases between shots.
>>> When Lisa goes to Jeff's house to celebrate his last week with his cast,
she places two candles onto the table next to him, the candles are not lit.
A little later in the same scene, Lisa walks into the kitchen, and when she
returns, the candles are lit.
>>> The location and angle of the shadows of the "sun" are in the same place
at in the morning and at night.
>>> At the end of Jeff's first massage, Stella places the bottle with the
green liquid on the side table without replacing the cap. As Stella is
packing to leave, the bottle is capped as she places it in her bag.
>>> On the back of the DVD cover, on the version's issued in Australia & the
UK, James Stewart's character's name is referred to as J. B. Jeffries
instead of L. B. Jeffries. |
|
| 1953 |
I Confess/Ich beichte/Zum Schweigen verurteilt |
|
>>> While Ruth waits for her husband beside the door of the
city council, a thin old man enters and walks until the desk and then
disappears between shots.
>>> After the guests leave, Ruth begins tidying and her left arm is bare
under a long band of her dress. When her husband enters in the room, her arm
is covered, with the dress band held between her left arm and her body.
>>> When Pierre comes into her bedroom, Ruth sits on the bed with her right
arm leaning on the bed. In the next shot her right arm is extended on her
right leg.
>>> In the scene where Ruth is watching the postman walk past her house, set
during World War II, the cars parked on the street are all 1950s models.
>>> Just before Logan accidentally smashes the car window when he's attacked
by the mob, the window can clearly be seen to have been "pre-cracked" to
allow it to break upon impact. |
|
| 1951 |
Strangers on a Train/Verschwörung im Nordexpreß/Der Fremde im Zug |
|
>>> In the scene where Guy enters Bruno's
house to kill his father, Guy takes out a flashlight to look at Bruno's map.
In one shot, you can only see the map, and the light is very small and
circular, but in a wider shot of Guy's upper torso, the light covers most
all of the map.
>>> Farley Granger meets a math professor
on a train bound from New York to Washington, and is able to prove as much
to the police. The professor got on in New York and got off in Wilmington,
DE, while Granger boarded the train in the fictitious town of Metcalf, NJ,
and rode on to Washington. Thus, they met between Metcalf and Wilmington.
But the police say Granger could have boarded the train in Baltimore, by
which time the professor would have gotten off and they never would have
met.
>>> At one point in the tennis match, Guy
hits a ball that bounces twice before his opponent can get to it, but it is
not called.
>>> When Bruno is on his way to Union
Station, he's heading on a bridge away from the Lincoln Memorial, which
means he's leaving Washington D.C. for Arlington, Virginia, or in other
words, he's going the wrong way.
>>> When Farley Granger sneaks out of his
flat to go to Robert Walker's house, there is an EXIT sign over the door.
Maybe in a theater or cinema, but in a private apartment?
>>> In the opening scene, two taxis pull
up at Washington Union Station with the Capitol visible in the background.
The Capitol is not visible from this point.
>>> When Bruno and Guy first meet on the
train Bruno orders some whiskies and lights a cigarette. He talks with this
in the corner of his mouth until the camera angle changes mid-sentence when
it disappears without him moving.
>>> If Guy was in such a hurry to get out
of there, couldn't he have much more easily lost the match in three sets?
Surely, a match loss would be a small price to pay to alleviate a murder
charge.
>>> When Guy is on the train returning to Metcalf (after the tennis
match) you can see over his shoulder that the sun has almost completely set
- but the next scene shows Bruno (in line to go back to the island) looking
up to see the full sun in the sky.
>>> When Guy is in Bruno's house, the beam of the flashlight is not
consistent between the shot of Guy looking at the map, and the upward shot
of Guy looking around to get his bearings.
>>> When Miriam's glasses drop to the ground as Bruno strangles
her, they land softly on the grass and don't break. However after the
struggle, when he reaches down to pick them up they are seen to be cracked
in one of the lenses.
>>> During the initial conversation on the train, Bruno's cigarette
vanishes from his mouth mid-sentence.
>>> Tennis match played before the end of the movie is clearly put
together from 2 different games - you can see those are different tennis
courts and also stadiums.
>>> When Bruno is kicking Guy on the merry-go-round, he is not
holding the cigarette lighter, but when he dies, he has it in his hand.
>>> In Bruno's house, the dog on the top of the stairs has stiff
ears. That one which licks the Guy's hand in close-up, differently, has
flexible ears.
>>> As Bruno approaches the fairground, following Miriam, the
position of his hands changes between shots, from clasped behind his back,
to lighting a cigarette.
>>> A crew member is reflected in the car door when the two
detectives get out of the car at the station they have chased Guy to.
>>> The hand that grasps the cigarette lighter in the drain has
shorter fingernails than Bruno's hand, as is evident when Bruno's hand is
opened in the final fairground scene.
>>> When Bruno takes a taxi from the Anthony house in Arlington,
Virginia, to travel to Union Station in Washington, the taxi crosses a
bridge over the Potomac River, which separates Virginia and Washington, D.C.
The taxi is crossing the bridge in the wrong direction, because the Lincoln
Memorial and Washington Monument (located in D.C.) are shown through the
rear window of the taxi.
>>> When Turley and the detective follow Guy to the station, they
see him at the ticket booth. As they carry on to follow him, several people
in the background walking through the station and going up the escalator can
be seen looking and pointing towards the camera and crew. |
|
| 1950 |
Stage Fright/Die rote Lola |
|
>>> At the charity fair it is raining and everyone
holds an umbrella. Shots of shoes and the ground show that they are dry.
>>> When Charlotte is testing a black dress, she holds a lit
cigarette which disappears between shots.
>>> The way that Johnny carries Charlotte's blue dress changes
between shots. |
|
| 1949 |
Under Capricorn/Sklavin des Herzens |
|
>>> As the characters gather for the dinner party,
fairly early on in the film, the camera tracks backwards across the dining
room. The table has been pushed into the path of the camera by the time it
comes into view, but the candlesticks are still shaking severely from the
jerking appearance of the table (their shaking lessens as the take continues). |
|
| 1948 |
Rope/Cocktail für eine Leiche |
|
>>> During the dinner party, Philip
crushes a glass in his hand, and we see that his hand is cut and bloody
before he wraps a piece of cloth around it. Later on, when Mrs. Atwater
reads his palms, not only is there no bandage, but there is also no blood or
sign of a cut on his hand.
>>> When Phillip plays on the piano, the
music doesn't match his finger movements.
>>> When David is killed in the very
first scene, the two men lay him neatly in the big chest, the rope does not
hang out the side. But then one man bends over and discovers the rope
halfway hanging out of the side of the chest.
>>> When Rupert gives ice cream to
Brandon, they are besides a wall between the living room and the entrance of
the house but the shot later, they are on the other side of it.
>>> Philip's piano playing does not match the music playing.
>>> When Rupert describes how he would "get rid" of David, the
camera pans from the easy chair to the piano. When it returns to the chair
about ten seconds later, the chair is facing a different direction.
>>> When Rupert is talking to Brandon and holding two plates of ice
cream, the camera moves behind Brandon's back to make a cut. When the camera
re-emerges, Rupert and Brandon are standing in the same positions, but the
doorway background is in a different place. Also, the ice cream topping has
changed from chocolate to caramel. Furthermore, the piece of cake changes
position on the plate in Rupert's left hand - it moves to the opposite side.
>>> Philip cuts his hand on glass, but moments later there's no
blood or wound visible.
>>> With a cigarette in his left hand, Brandon makes a quick phone
call to the garage man. After he hangs up the phone he has no cigarette.
>>> When Phillip and Brandon put David in the chest, the rope is
clearly around David's neck and completely inside the box. But in a few
minutes Phillip finds the rope hanging, very far, outside the box.
>>> During the party, the chest that houses David is tall enough to
serve food from. However, by the end, as Rupert crosses to the chair next to
it, the chest is only as tall as Rupert's knees.
>>> Clouds in the background do not move, revealing that the
background is painted. |
|
| 1947 |
The Paradine Case/Der Fall Paradin |
|
>>> When Gay gives Mr. Keane a drink, she
completely empties the cocktail shaker. However, after she gives him the
drink, she takes the same cocktail shaker and supplies a drink for herself.
>>> When Latour is seen in close-up in the court, there is a man on
either side of him. In the long shots, there is nobody near him.
>>> Although the film story is all based in UK, but almost all of
the characters speak in an American accent. |
|
| 1946 |
Notorious/Weisses Gift, Berüchtigt |
|
>>> When CG and IB are on the plane,
watch the scenery in the window. It appears to be going in reverse.
>>> Watch Devlin's hands in the cafe in
Rio. They open and close between shots.
>>> When Devlin and Alicia are having a drink at an outside table
in a busy cafe, the same portion of background film was used in two separate
parts of their dialogue (a man walks away from the camera, then a waiter
approaches a distant table and starts to put down some drinks from his tray).
>>> At the coffee shop in Rio, Devlin's hands are repeatedly folded/unfolded
between shots.
>>> When Alicia and Devlin are flying to South America, the
movement of the clouds makes it appear that the plane is flying backwards.
>>> When Devlin visits Alicia sick in bed, she says, "They are
poisoning me," and continues to speak, but her lips do not move.
>>> Alicia and Devlin's shadows can be seen "over" the background
plates during the drunk driving scene and the balcony scene.
>>> When the motorcycle officer is approaching Alicia's car, the
rear-view mirror has the same image as we see behind Devlin and Alicia, not
the reverse.
>>> In the scene where Devlin and Alicia go to find Sebastian
riding horses there is a quick two second shot of all four characters next
to each other on horses and two arms are visible walking the horses of
Sebastian and the woman he is riding with.
>>> When Devlin and Alicia go to find Sebastian riding horses, when
viewed from the front Alicia is nearest to the rails. When viewed from
behind their positions are reversed and Alicia's horse has changed from
chestnut to dapple gray.
>>> When Alicia picks up Alex's keys off the dresser, it is a round
key she is after. However, the key we see in her fingers immediately after
removing it from the ring is not round.
>>> When Alicia and Devlin are riding their horses (and about to
meet up with Sabastian), the shadow of the microphone boom can clearly be
seen as it passes over Alicia's face when they ride out from under the trees. |
|
| 1945 |
Spellbound/Ich
kämpfe um dich |
|
>>> The "hand" holding the gun rotates
180 degrees while the shooter's point of view does not move. A real hand
can't reproduce that motion without moving extremely close to the face.
>>> Immediately after the (Dali) dream
sequence, when Dr. Brulov and Constance are reviewing Constance's notes, Dr.
Brulov draws a pencil out of his coat pocket. Hitchcock then cuts to a
close-up, and Dr. Brulov repeats the motion.
>>> During Ingrid Bergman's first scene,
she is having a psychiatric session with a patient. Suddenly, you hear the
sound of the door opening. The camera immediately goes to the door, showing
two men standing side by side, both perfectly still and standing in a place
that would have required more movement than the time allotted between shot
changes. * Abfolgefehler: When Dr. Peterson enters the library at the mental
hospital, The word "LIBRARY" is clearly visible on the door in large letters.
When she exits, it is gone.
>>> When John Ballantine, after seeing snow in Dr. Brulov's house,
drops and breaks a cup full of coffee, no coffee spills on the carpet.
>>> When Dr. Brulov wakes J.B. to ask about his dreams, J.B.'s hair
is very messed up. However, when Dr. Peterson enters the room with coffee a
couple of minutes later, J.B.'s hair is neat, even though he hasn't combed
it.
>>> The envelope which John Ballantine slips under the door of Dr.
Peterson's room remains close the door and with its border parallel to the
door bottom line. Later it appears a little distant from the door and skewed.
>>> The burn on JB's hand is only visible during the scene where
they talk about it. It disappears in every other scene where his hand is
visible (like when he is sitting on the couch with Dr Brulow). |
|
| 1944 |
Lifeboat/Das Rettungsboot |
|
>>> After the operation on Gus's leg, the group is
playing cards. The sound is the same audio from the card game earlier in the
film. Ritt stays. Kovac takes three cards. You can see when Kovac supposedly
says, "Three cards," his lips don't move at all.
>>> When Gus is chugging brandy, the amount in the bottle remains
the same and does not go down.
>>> When Talulah offers to use her diamond bracelet as a fishing
lure, the fish that swallows it is a carp, a fresh water fish, which would
be unlikely to strike at a flashy lure anyway since it is a toothless
herbivore.
>>> The fish that is seen underwater going after Connie's gem bait
is obviously being pulled to it by a line attached to its mouth, and never
opens its mouth to take the object when it makes its "strike". |
|
| 1943 |
Shadow of a Doubt/Im Schatten des Zweifels |
|
>>> In the pull-back shot from "Young"
Charlie while she's in the library, the shadow of the camera is visible on
her back.
>>> As the car/cab pulls out in the scene
where the group leaves for Uncle Charlie's speech a man is seen disappearing
around the right side of the house, but no one is supposed to be there but
Young Charlie.
>>> When Young Charlie is reading the newspaper in the library, the camera
casts a shadow on her back.
>>> In the beginning of the film, when the maid enters in the Uncle
Charlie's bedroom, he is lying on the bed with his hands crossed on his
belly holding a cigar. For a moment he appears with his hands and the cigar
on his chest.
>>> When Uncle Charlie goes out home, the two men outside follow him. A shot
from above shows them with very short shadows, showing that is around noon.
They separate for a short while and when they meet, their shadows are much
longer, though not enough time has passed for it to be that much later.
>>> Near the beginning of the movie, little Ann answers the phone when the
telegraph office calls. She delivers all her responses without pausing long
enough to allow the caller to respond.
>>> Uncle Charlie is on Locomotive No. 140 shown heading to Santa Rosa. When
the Train pulls into the station and is met by the family, Locomotive No.
142 arrives.
>>> When Charlie examines the ring at the library, the manner the ring is
held in the closeup is not the same as immediately before or after. |
|
| 1942 |
Saboteur/Saboteure |
|
>>> The closeup of the Soda City calendar
shows a much heavier coating of spider webs than the previous shot.
>>> After arriving at the Statue of
Liberty, a closeup shows Priscilla Lane in a very strong wind which musses
her hair. In the next shot, her hair is perfect. |
|
| 1941 |
Suspicion/Verdacht |
|
>>> After returning from their honeymoon, Johnnie pours tea
for Lina. He picks up the teapot, then lifts it again in the cutaway shot.
>>> When Lina reads the notice of the Beaky's death, the wall behind her
changes at times.
>>> When Lina looks at Isobel's book while Johnnie is on the telephone,
there is a large tear in the book jacket above Isobel's photo. In the next
scene, when Lina takes the book on her visit to Isobel, the book jacket is
undamaged.
>>> According to the invitation shown on screen, the hunt ball is on March
7, but the telegram that persuades Lina to attend the ball is dated March 8.
>>> Hitchcock makes his cameo appearance about forty minutes in, posting a
letter in the village. However, when the shot changes, he has suddenly
disappeared from beside the pillar-box.
>>> Hitchcock makes his cameo appearance about forty minutes in, posting a
letter in the village. Note the background in this shot and a shot just a
few seconds earlier with the car driving by and a man walking while smoking.
They are both exactly the same background shot with same car, people, with
one being enlarged. It could be the film was so expensive, the re-use of
background shots was needed.
>>> The barrister's lips and speech are out of sync when reading Lina's
father's will. |
|
| 1940 |
Foreign Correspondent/Mord/Der Auslandskorrespondent |
|
>>> Despite the explicit dialogue and written appearances of
the name that make it clear that the character Scott ffolliott has no
capital F, the name still appears as Ffolliott in the end credit cast list.
>>> Window shadow on Johnny's jacket changes while in his boss's office.
>>> Johnny's raincoat lapel is folded, then flat, then folded while on the
steps in the rain.
>>> The ladder appears and disappears beside the windmill door.
>>> The taxi rear window view shows that they drive up the same street twice.
>>> The film is reversed left-to-right during the chess game at the police
station.
>>> During the plane crash climax, during the montage of images after the
plane hits the water, the camera tilts too high up and the lights of the set
can be seen.
>>> As the arguing couple depart the elevator at the top of the cathedral
tower, its walls can be seen to shake hugely.
>>> When ffolliott returns with backup to find van Meer unconscious on the
bed, and the room deserted, the doorframe shakes noticeably as the actors
pass through it.
>>> As the Purser on the ship tells John and Carol that he has no more
cabins, the right side of his fake moustache can be seen sliding down. He
surreptitiously pushes back in place, but as they turn back for a second try
and he continues speaking, the moustache slides down again.
>>> When Johnny and Carol step down from the taxi in front of her house, he
takes the suitcase with her left hand and changes it to the right one, to
direct her with the left hand. After the taxi leaves, he is holding the
suitcase in his left hand.
>>> In Fisher's office, Scott picks up a cigarette from the cigarette case
and puts it in his mouth. The following shot shows him smoking, without
apparently lighting the cigarette at all.
>>> After the crash, as the survivors spot the American ship steaming toward
them, the matte line between the moving water and the sky can easily be seen.
>>> During the scene where the passengers are scrambling to get out of the
sinking Clipper, a man grabs a suitcase and smashes a window, leaving a lot
of large, jagged pieces of glass in the frame. He then climbs through the
window and sits directly on the jagged glass.
>>> The streetcars are obvious dummies running on rubber tires.
>>> The hair of Carol Fisher is wet after she completely submerges next to
ffolliott after the plane crash. In the exact next shot her hair is nearly
dry again. |
|
| 1940 |
Rebecca |
|
>>> In the scene where Max de Winter
brings Mrs. de Winter to Manderley for the first time, we see Frith, the
butler, at the estate gates. A few minutes later, after the de Winters have
finished driving down their mile-long driveway, we see him at the front door
of the mansion. How'd he make it back there so fast?
>>> When Maxim gives Mrs. de Winter the
bushel of flowers, right after they are married, she says a few times "lovely",
the last time she says it, her mouth is closed.
>>> Camera dollying back from Mrs. de Winter sitting on a chair
brushes some flowers on a table.
>>> When The Second Mrs. de Winter and Maxim marry, he gives her a
large bunch of flowers. She repeats "Perfectly lovely", but the second time,
her lips do not move.
>>> After the luncheon, de Winter and "I" are standing on the steps
waving goodbye, Jasper the dog moves from one side of the steps to the other
between shots.
>>> When the new Mrs. De Winter first enters the room to do her
correspondence, there are three books on the table. An establishing shot
shows that the book on the left is labeled "menus", and the one in the
center is labeled "addresses". Mrs. de Winter picks up the one on the left,
and it is now revealed in a close-up to read "addresses" on the cover.
>>> Frank's hand holding the letter jumps from in front of the
filing cabinet to resting on top of it.
>>> During the dining scene after the second Mrs. de Winter knocks
over the vase, the neckline of her blouse goes from untidy to perfectly neat
between shots.
>>> Walking back from the beach, the background moves much more
quickly than the characters.
>>> In the Monte-Carlo Hotel Lounge, the 'girl' and Mrs Van Hopper
are having coffee. The 'girl's' coffee cup then a newspaper are in her right
hand between shots without sufficient time or obvious motion to change them.
>>> George is driving on the left-hand side of the road outside
Monte Carlo.
>>> The second Mrs. De Winter follows Jasper to the cottage. When
she sees Jasper, he is standing up, barking in front of the door. She
approaches the door and the dog is now lying to one side. |
|
| 1939 |
Jamaica Inn/Riff-Piraten |
|
>>> In the first scene where the wreckers are
assembled at the inn, Dandy's many tattoos are shown in close-up and feature
prominently as he recalls a past love affair commemorated in one of them.
Yet in one tableau view of the gang from that same scene, there's not a
single tattoo to be seen on his chest under his open coat. |
|
| 1938 |
The Lady Vanishes/Eine Dame verschwindet |
|
>>> Ms Froy's writing on the window has
changed position when Iris spots it later.
>>> When Iris Henderson and her two
friends arrive at the hotel, Iris orders dinner and asks that it be sent up
to "our" room. The waiter arrives when the three are changing. But later,
when it's time for bed, Iris says good night to her friends, who leave her
alone in the room (as she must be for the sake of subsequent developments).
>>> Iris, Gilbert and the other English
characters lose their luggage when the bad guys have the back of the train
uncoupled. When they arrive in London at the end, Iris and Gilbert are
wearing new clothes evidently acquired after their escape. However, they
carry nothing when they leave the train. What happened to the clothes they
had been wearing before?
>>> When Iris, Gilbert and Dr. Hartz are
together in the dining car, they order three drinks, one for each of them.
Gilbert swallows his in one gulp. A minute later, Dr. Hartz proposes a
toast, and all three of them guzzle their drinks. Where did Gilbert get
another glass of brandy?
>>> Margaret tells her lover Eric that
her husband thinks she's "cruising with Mother." Afterwards, when the
villains are closing in for the kill, she tells the others, "It's funny: I
told my husband when I left him that I wouldn't see him again" - hardly the
sort of thing you tell your spouse after telling him a story to cover up
your infidelity.
>>> When Iris is about to hit the still semi-conscious Signor Doppo, for the
second time, he cringes before she hits him.
>>> Just after the train starts out, we see it on a high bridge; behind the
locomotive and tender are a van, four passenger cars, and another van. Just
after the lady vanishes, an exterior view along the side of the train shows
at least five passenger cars, and we were told that there have been no stops.
>>> In Europe, the hotel manager says it is "spring" when talking about the
avalanches. However, the two English travelers are trying to get back to the
Manchester cricket test in England. Cricket is played in the summer and all
Manchester tests in the 1930s were played in July.
>>> The writing on the train window.
>>> During the club car scene where Dr. Hartz tries to get Gilbert and Iris
to drink drugged brandies, the amount of brandy in the snifters varies from
shot to shot.
>>> The way Charters leans over Caldicott in bed when the maid enters
changes between shots.
>>> The way Iris leans on her pillow when Gilbert enters her room changes
between shots. |
|
| 1936 |
Sabotage/The
Woman Alone/Sabotage |
|
>>> The London Underground and tram lines had their own
power supplies, both separate from the public system. A single power station
failure could not affect all three.
>>> Stevie's hair and the foam on his mouth as he is being subjected to the
street vendor.
>>> The layout of the letter Verloc is writing.
>>> The ring on Mrs. Verloc's third finger when she's wielding the knife. |
|
| 1936 |
The Secret Agent/Geheimagent |
|
>>> When the little dog is scratching at the door, it is
facing left and is in front of the right-side door. When the elderly lady
then (immediately) picks up the dog, it is facing right and is in front of
the left-side door.
>>> Ashenden's resignation letter changes between scenes. The first time we
see it, it reads: "Now that I have resigned / if you want a successor for /
me I can give you the / name of a good reliable butcher" When Carrington
later looks at it and cuts it up, it reads: "Now that I have resigned / if
you want a successor / for me I can give you / the name of a good / reliable
butcher"
>>> The General (Peter Lorre) drops his hat in the church and then he runs
upstairs together with Edgar Brodie (John Gielgud). When they get there he
has his hat on again.
>>> Dates given in the story are out of sequence. After starting "May 10,
1916" (title), a telegram received later appears to be dated "3/4/16". A
newspaper near the end of the film is dated "Tuesday, September 21, 1916,"
when that date actually occurred on a Thursday. Afterwards a postcard bears
the date of "April 2."
>>> Though the film is set in 1916, most of the women's fashions are
contemporary with 1936. |
|
| 1935 |
The Thity-nine Steps/Die 39 Stufen |
|
>>> Lights visible when police search the train.
>>> Shadow of microphone visible on wood panelling in hotel room.
>>> When Professor Jordan suggests Richard Hannay commit suicide, he says "What
if I leave you alone with this revolver?" when he is clearly brandishing a
small-caliber semi-auto pistol.
>>> The serial number of the autogyro has been reversed, showing that the
stock shot has been reversed for effect.
>>> The date in the Church Hymnary that stopped the bullet is signed by
Margaret in 1928, but is dated 1932.
>>> The sideways shots into the car that Richard and Pamela are travelling
in with the detectives uses the same view across a loch, even though the
following shots show they are nowhere near water.
>>> Just before Professor Jordan shoots Hannay, his revolver impossibly
switches from his left to right hand.
>>> Near the beginning of the film in the scene with the Memory Man
entertaining the audience by answering their questions a woman yells out, "Who
is the last British Heavyweight champion of the world?". Beside her is a man
who mouths the woman's words in synch with her. |
|
| 1934 |
The Man Who Knew Too Much/"Der Mann, der zuviel wußte" |
|
>>> In the scene where the man is shot through the window,
near the beginning of the film, just before he is shot, he turns to face
another man. At that time, you can see the beginnings of a blood stain on
his shirt next to his lapel...before he’s shot! |
|
| 1932 |
Rich and Strange/East of Shanghai/Endlich sind wir reich |
|
>>> In an early scene, Emily is shown using a marker to draw
a caricature of herself into a photograph with Commander Gordon. The photo
is shown again two more times in the movie, and each time the drawing is
slightly different. |
|
| 1929 |
Blackmail/Erpressung |
|
>>> The painting changes from the time it
is made until the time the detective looks at it.
>>> When the artist is talking to the landlady, his walking stick
is tucked under his arm. When he turns around, it is hanging on his forearm.
>>> When the artist is talking to Alice (Anny Ondra), he calls her
Annie at one point, before correcting himself.
>>> It is obvious that Mr. Crewe (the artist) is never actually
playing the piano. Rather than pushing them down, his fingers just touch the
piano keys.
>>> Before the chase scene, Alice Locks the door so the blackmailer
cannot escape while Frank explains that the squad car is on its way. When
the other officers arrive, they enter the door without unlocking it.
>>> After leaving the artist's loft, Alice walks through the
streets of London. Throughout the walk, her shoes alternate between heels
and pumps.
>>> A policeman stops the cab with a fleeing Tracy, and the officer
looks into the cab standing no more than a foot from the bumper. When the
panicky Tracy flees the cab, the bobby is ten feet from the taxi's front and
is facing in the opposite direction. |
|
| 1926 |
The Lodger.
A Story of the London Fog/The Case of Jonathan Drew/Der Mieter |
|
>>> When the lodger is looking down the
stairs at Daisy (who has just been handcuffed as a joke), his body faces the
railing in one shot, the wall in the next, then the railing again.
>>> After "the lodger" escapes handcuffed, Daisy met him sitting on
a bank in the street. Then she sits down side by side with him. After that
he puts his head on her right shoulder, with his face touching her face.
Between shots she appears alone with nobody on her shoulder.
>>> In one of the heralded shots of the film, Daisy and her parents
look at the ceiling to see the chandelier shaking. We then see "through" the
ceiling to a shot of the Lodger's feet pacing back and forth. This was a
unique way to imply the sound of footsteps in a silent film. However,
looking at the layout of the house, the room the family is in is NOT beneath
the room in which the Lodger is pacing. |
|
|
|